Three Claimants to a Motor Car In the United States Court for China, on Tuesday, his Honour Judge C. S. Lobingier gave a written judgment in the case of R. T. Ryton v. H. S. Honigsberg Ca., Inc., stating in part:—
This is an action of replevin for an automobile delivered by defendant to H. A. Clifton under an agreement of conditional sale. The petition alleges purchase by plaintiff from the vendee without notice. No answer seems to have been filed, but counsel for both parties have signed an "agreed statement of facts' by which it appears that the purchase price was Ts. 3,300, of which the purchaser paid Tls. 2,350 and received for his rights Tls. 2,000 from plaintiff. It is admitted that defendant obtained an injunction in the court of plaintiff's nation restraining him from disposing of the car but that this proceeding was afterwards abandoned and that thereafter the defendant _obtained a judgment against Clifton in H. B. M. Supreme Court for the balance of instalments due; that the defendant caused the motor car to be removed from a public road within the International Settlement, and from the plaintiff's possession, into its, the defendant's garage. It is conceded that by the weight of authority this obtaining of judgment constituted a waiver of defendant's claim to the property.
Tt is urged that defendant's judgment has never been satisfied. That fact dors not appear in the agreed statement nor by any evidence, but we do not think a different conclusion would follow had such fact been shown.
The interesting question the effect of consular registration of sale agreements need not be determined here, but it would seem that such registration constitutes at least a wise precaution. It appearing that plaintiff has acquired the rights of the purchaser and that the latter, by the ndgment against him, was re cognized as the owner of the car, it is hereby. considered and ad-indeed that plaintiff have and recover possession thereof, - together with costs.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.