Mr, Faison, in reply, said it must Jo obvious to the Court that defendants' contention, was untenable in law. Assuming that defendant company were liable for the acts of its agents, surely the Court was the only possible court in which the plaintiff could bring a charge against defendant company for the negligence of its agents or servants. Mr.
Ward. had proceeded on the basis that the allegations in plaintiff's second cause of action were true. That being the case, for the puiposes of the argument iti must be admitted that the medical services furnished to plaintiff were not only incompetent, but insufficient. Evidence would be given to show that plaintiff had been permanently lamed through the failure of defendants' doctors, and that he was given chloroform four times within chant 40 days, with the -result that his heart hiad been seriously affected.
"Mr. Faison' asserts with an amount of confidence that is surprising," said Mr, Ward, "that the doctors were the servants and agents of the company. In other words (counsel proceeded) if your servant was injured in your house. and you were kind enough to send our doctor to attend him, and at same time paid for that attendance, the doctor thereupon became your servant. There were no allegations in the petition that the doctors were the servants or agents of the company. If your servant did an act which he knew at the time was dangerous and foolish and you were good enough to provide him with the services of your medical attendant, he could then turn round on you and claim damages on the ground that. the doctors did not know their business."
The hearing of the motion was adjourned until Tuesday.
When the case of A. M. Vinopradoff 7. the China Merchants S. N. Ca. was resumed at the Mixed Court on Tuesday, Mr. Ivanoff (Senior Consul's Assessor) and Magistrate Tsang sustained the miction by defendants -that plaintiff's second cause of
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.