The Archive · 1929

British Navy in Parliament

Questions in Commons and Debate in Lords on British Cruisers4

Earl Beatty's Grave Warning: Britain Approaching Dangerous Minimum London, Dec. 18, question time in the House of Commons to-day Mr. W. T. Kelly, Labour member for Rochdale, asked what would be the saving in the Naval estimates if in each of the next three years it was decided not to replace any of the battleships. now in.commission. He also asked what would be the additional saving if half the number of battleships now in commission were scrapped.

Mr. C. C. Amman, Financial Secretary to the Admiralty, replied that the battleship replacement, programme, contained in the Washington Naval Agreement, provided that two new battleships should be laid down by the British Empire in 1931 and two more in 1992. Assuming that such were the maximum permissible displacement the est mated cost in 1930 would be nil, 1981 it would be 1,030,000 and in 1932, 26,065,000.

As regarded the second part of the question, Mr. Amman stated that the annual cost of maintenance of eight of the 16 existing battleships was for roughly £2,300,000 of which £1,500,000 was for pay, allowances, insurance, victualling, ete. He was unable to say what would be the actual effect on the Naval estimates of the policy indicated by the questioner.

Brig-General Sir Henry Page Croft, Conservative member for Bournemouth, asked whether the Government would see that the monies thus "obtained under false, pretences" would be returned to the' contributors.

Mr. Alexander did not reply.

The New German Cruiser A debate in the House of Lords on the subject of the reduction in British cruisers was initiated today on a motion by Earl Stanhope, who instanced that Germany non-participant in the Ws Conference, had legitimately 10,000 ton cruiser, which was well armed, and too fast to be caught by a battleship, and too handled by' any Washington limitations.

The only vessel, he said, capable of coping with the situation was a battle cruiser, and the maintenance of battle cruisers would necessitate larger mumber of battleships. than would otherwise be necessary.

Earl Beatty declared that Britain, was approaching the Naval limita~ tion Conference with. figures repre senting 2 dangerous minimum. The extremely low limit of eruisee tonnage, he remarked, caused.ap-Prehension among those who had given consideration to this vital Continuing, Earl Beatty. said unable to understand how parity in cruisers could be achieved unless it was to be a parity having regard to the commitments and obligations of each nation.

Lord Thomson, Minister for: Airy save an assurance that the Govern ment policy vis-a-vis of the security of the Empire was unaltered on Single point. He said if the Conference succeeded, the Government were confident that the Admiralty would be able to continue adequately to discharge their responsibilities of naval defence. He assured Earl Beatty, however, that the Govern ment would carefully note his marks. a The Singapore Base Adverting to the Singapore Base, Earl Stanhope asserted that much work had been carried out in recent' years upon Naval Bases in Japan and in the Hawaiian Islands, and, therefore, it was incomprehensible that the Government should expect Japan and the United States mark upon what Britain was doing at Singapore, Lord Thomson declared that the Government did not intend to uso the Singapore scheme as a bargaining counter at the Naval Conference. They were entering the Conference with clean hands, and if they achieved the hoped for suc cess, they would lieable to apply some of the results of that sue-cess to the Singapore scheme. Any proposal affecting the scheme as a whole, or the date of its completion, would, he said, be made the subject of full consultation with the Governments of the Dominions, Malaya and,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account