The Archive · 1936

A Straight Issue

Aprit 2.

Yesterday was the date for enforcing the new rate of daily rental of rickshaws by pullers from the owners reduced from '78 cents big money {to 70 cents, It was anticipated from the attitude which the rickshaw owners carly acopted—one of truculent resistance—that there woul be immediate developments, and it was apparent early in the day that they were carrying out their threat to hold their vehicles off the street until their views wer accepted by the municipal author ties. At the time of writing it was not possible to ascertain exactly what proportion of rickshaws had. been withheld from the pullers. but the condition of the streets in this respect suggested that a very large number had been withdrawn in the morning, a ratio which greatly injereased Jater in the day when the night-shift men went off work. 'The technique of the owners is apparent, By refusing to rent their' vehicles the pullers and prevent. ing ther. from earning their livelihood, it is expected that in a very few days they will become desperate and create disorder for the embarrassment of the authorities. It is by no means unlikely that the owners will uso bad! characters for the purpose of fomenting trouble as they are aiteged to have done on previous occasions, and it is clear from their of a memorandum which deserves careful attention, In a controversy there are usually three views: the view of one party, the view of the other and—the correct view. IL actions of yesterday that they are is for Germany, as one party, and perfectly callous concerning what the four Locarno Powers, as the suffering their actions may involve other, to strive by consultation to so long as they are able to impose arrive at the correct view and their will upon a community which adjust their policies accordingly. M. has been deeply stirred by the Flandin, the other day, put. some velations which were made in the pertinent questions to Herr Hitler. report of the Rickshaw Commis-'They are not directly answered in sion. That is the definite issue with the memorandum now presented by which, they are facing the authori Germany, but it is fair to say that ies of the International Settlement, they are in certain important and ils seriousness lies in the fact respects so well covered that the that a. small coterie of men, who task of reconcilement should not be have been battening on the unfor-impossible, provided due allowance tunate rickshaw puller for many be made for differences of outlook. years past, should have the hard and circumstance, To M. Flandin hood to set the authorities at de-the tassie issue is France's security; fiance. to Herr Hitler it is the establish-In their statement concerning the ment of Germany's status of annual report of the Rickshaw equality. Both are essential factors Board the owners have sought to in the maintenance of European traverse practically everything the peace, In so far as the crisis has Board has said, and by innuendo to awakened uneasiness over the in-make charges which would not bear of treaty obligations, Herr the slightest investigation. It -is Hiller secks, apparently, to dis because of their desire to present criminate between undertakings some sort of case, if only to bolster which he regards as "unilaterally up their own unfortunate altitude, onerous" and, therefore, in despite that they handled the truth with a of Germany's dignity as_a free carelessness which amounts to. irtion and those {6 which Germany reverence. The fact is that while is an equal party with other powers. all the progress which was at first Whether that formula can be made desired has not been made, much to fit in with Mr, Anthony Eden's has been done to alleviate the lot comments and M, Flandin's cate-of the puller. 'The report of the torical demands will be for Pullers' Mutual Ald Association, diplomatic skill to determine. published a few weeks back bears were inappropriate here to ample testimony to that fact, The attempt to examine the German pullers have undoubledly benefitted memorandum in detail, Least of all from the first reduction in rickshaw should dialectical energy be rental which followed the publica~ pended on its incursion into the tion of the Commission's report and ethics of the Peace Treaties. It it has yet to be proved that any common ground that Herr Hitler rickshaw hong has been forced out is right when he proposes the of business because of the reduc-separation of the Covenantgrora the tion that was then made. Indeed Treaty of Versailles. It 8 not so the vehemence with which they easy {o devise means for giving imseek {0 preserve their present posi-mediate effect to that feeling. That tion is an indication that the rick-is implicitly recognized in the state= shaw renting business is still a very ment of Germany's readiness, under profitable one. In any considera~ certain conditions, to re-enter the tion of this question it has to be League of Nations. Therein lies the borne in mind that the very high importance of the three stages value placed on the rickshaw has which the memorandum prescribes: arisen from the illegal acts of the first a preparatory period for rickshaw owners who brought it securing the necessary calmness of about by contravention of the res-Jalmosphere, secondly actual negotiaulations under which they were tions for organizing security and ranted their licences. That some! thirdly the consolidation of Europ-hardship must be inflicted upon can peace by tackling supplement those who purchased their vehicles: ary problems such as disarmament and licences on the top of the and economic rehabilitation. market is {0 some extent to be will be noted that the nineteen regretted, but it is most certainly points subsequently outlined in the reason for continuing the com= plan itself begin with an explicit pletely bad practices which the desire to "give fulure agreements to Municipal Council, through the ensure the peace of Europe the Rickshaw Board, are seeking to character of inviolability." Tkwould correct. be impossible {0 question the These aspects of the case have sincerity of that exordium without been dealt with ad nauseam in the charging the German Government past, but it is just as well that they with an incredible cynicism. should be briefly recalled fact, supported by the German circumstances stich as have _pre~ people, Herr Hitler once again as~ vailed since yesterday morning, serts his pacific intentions. He will The issue is a perfectly straight find himself met more than halt one, Are the Council or the tick way if, in his turn, he can develop shaw owners going to govern in this, an appreciation of the conditions in settlement? It is eminently desir= which the nations so ae-iressed able that a solution of the present have to consider his plan as a whole. difficulties should be sought by It is practically certain that none negotiation and that every nerve of them will fail to recognize the should be strained to prevent. the opportunity offered, even if they outbreak of disorders, but the time feel impelled to" apply certain comes when the nevile has 9 be critical (eats to points both of detail grasped firmly and it is for the und of substance, Fickshaw owners to indicate their behaviour whether that time Her Hitler's methoris_are based has arrived or not. It may very on his own position in Germany—well be that the Council witl, in as the Leader o: a totalitarian state, which seems to" be It is natural therefore the facing it, consider means of extend should be inclined to frame his ing relief to the pullers who through the object of their own, will directly body of In the coun-the owners are being brought to a tries so addressed the systems of proper sense of their position.

1 Government and also of expressing, would seem that in the Pull judgment are different. Mutual Aid Association the: vantages and already established a nucleus of the Many of the necessary machinery which would speedily have to be put into com-dum deals are highly. technical mission. The provision of food for, and on them it is impossiblerfor lay the pullers appears to be a most, inion to be authoritatively me elementary precaution, though it by, formed. So, there Iwaye the no means averts the possibility that risk that the first reaction of the the owners, reverting to their old public to a document of this kind tactics, will avail themselves of the may be modified after expert the services of bad characters to stir have been An illustration up trouble, of which some slight of this dificully is to be found indications were to be noticed even the comment aroused by the ans yesterday. nouncement of the proposed talks between the French and British

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account