The Archive · 1924

MARCONI CONTRACTS

IN CHINA

Claim by Commission Agent:

Rebates of £80,000 Paid to Officials Mr. Godfrey Isaacs on March 22 gave evidence for the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Ca., Strand, London, in the action' brought against them by Mr. James A. Mal-calm, of Victoria Street, Westmi ter, heard by Mr. Justice Acton the King's Bench Divison, Plaintitt claimed commission of 5 per cent. on business done under three contracts with the Chinese Government. The Marconi Ca. had advanced money as well as supplied wireless telegraph material to the Chinese Government, and they denied that plaintiff, who, with a Mr. Birchal,' now deceased, was at-the time of the contracts their agent in China, was entitled to any commission on the loans to the Chinese Government.

Mr. W. A. Jowitt, x.c, for the Marconi Ca., said they had never before accepted an order for the sale of materials that was coupled with an obligation to lend money to the purchaser. On the general aspect of the ease he found this peculiar result in the case of two agents—that one was able to secure a clear order for the sal of £300,000 worth of goods and received a commission of 5 per cent., while the other agent got an order for £300,000 worth of goods with the onerous condition attached that £300,000 was to be lent. If the latter was to get_a commission twice over that woald be a curious conclusion to arrive at, Counsel suggested that to pay 5 per cent. commission on a loan was a ridiculous amount. He submitted that the parties in this case were thinking of 5 per cent. commission on orders for mate ials and not on the financial bu ness. In fact, done up to the death, and no business resulted from plaintiffs efforts. The bus ness was done apart from the tiff. Transactions with the Chinese Government, said Mr. Jowitt, could not be visualized in the same way fas could transactions with Western Governments. If the same code oF standard were applied as had to be applied in the case of our own government no orders at all would ever be got. When negotiations were started with the Chinese Government for the sale of anything to. them certain Chinese officials had to be, should he say, compensated,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account