The Archive · 1924

Prohibition in Working

To the Editor of the Nowri-CHINA DatLy News."

SiR,—Your correspondent, Mr. G. P. Bostick, asks us to read some extracts from the American press bearing on prohibition. May I in turn him to east his eye over the article "headed "Cross-Country Crime" which appeared in the "Ladies Home Journal" of June 19242 The following brief extracts will show that there is not yet much to boast of in the condition of post-prohibition America.

"Why are murder, theft, arson and all the other crimes five oe 10 times as frequent in the Unit-fed States as in any other country in the world—and that in proportion to the population?

who Americans and the Canadians have the same traditions and much the same institutions.

Why should we be 30 times as murderous?

"In New York City, with about six million people, there are 12 times ds many murders as in London, with a not much larger population; far more murders in New York City annually than in all the British isles. It is not the foreign-born population that does the evil, but the pure-blooded, honest, old one hundred per cent. American stock.

"It is stated that last year in the United States the thefts totaled. $3,000,000,000. A congress: announced that the—nation Capital is 2,000 per cent. more murderous than London and 300 per cent. more drunken than Paris; and while Washington has increased in population 32 per gent. in the last 10 years, murder slaughter 250 per cent., ous assault 307 per cent, Hiquor possession 700 per cent, liquor transportation 4,504 per cent. And this in the city built especially to house our legislative, executive and judicial machinery!'

"From high to low the shame prevails. 'The worst of it is the war over causes, responsibilities and cures. One' judge blames' the Federal officers. Another blames the local police. "Another blames the judges; another, the Juries that do not convict, though.

the gaols are so full that the ers can hardly be housed." especially draw Bfy.

attention to the last paragraph in view of the claim of one of his extracts that the criminal popu-Intion shows a decrease of per cent.

might add too that the death-rate in "wet" England is lower than that in "dry" America, This proves nothing, except perhaps that the English climate ix the better, but meanwhile we apparently have not much need to worry ourselves over the blessings of prohibition. uly 23, 1924,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account