A 16in, gun by itself is naturally a better weapon than a din, But the gun cannot be considered alone. On a certain tonnage. a ship is Capable of carrying a certain weight of material and no more. In a warship. this weight has to be distributed between the three main elements of armaments, speed and protection.
It follows that any increase of on of these elements has to be made at the expense of one or both of the others. Thus, if an increase of gun calibre from I4in. to 16in., involve heavier gui desired, something has to come off either speed or protection or "both It is on. this consideration that on! naval experts have based the a cision to retain the 14in, gun en a 35,000-ton displacement, whatever other countries may do.
The principal need is held to be not so much the largest gui pr the heaviest armour as what is called a well-balanced ship. By this is meant ship in which speed, armour and armament are all so nicely adjusted as to give the best general result, It will be obvious that a shizowith very heavy guns is badly designed it her protection is so meagre that she is liable to blow up if she is at all heavily hit milerly a well armed and protected ship \yould not be much use if she were teo slow coming into action It is this balancing up of the \ore main fietors, of fighting power which has led our Admiralty to choose the M4-inch gun as the most suitable one for a ship of It has been said that a 16-inch gu cannot, be mounted on a tonnage of less then 45,000 tone if a well-balanced ship is to be obtained. If, therefore, the Japanese and the Amer are proposing to mount 16 gun we may confidently assume that they will not only be deficient in speed or protection, but that this deficiency will more than counteract the advantage they gain from the heavier ordnance We had it brought home tous very forcibly in the war that larger guns by themselves were by no means the only criterion of victory.
The Old School Lessons from Jutland LirurdColonel LIG. F. Hay In the battle cruiser action in the Selene orca ne pected cadets of tne the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.