Cua for, $188,734 In compensation in an accident when a motor car ran Into the Whangpoo River and seven men were drowned.
Counse.: Mr. 12 D. Rodger for Plain tts; Mr. RT Bryan, Munlefpal Advorate, for SMC.
Before Sir John Brenan, H.M, Consul-General; "Mr. C. E. Gauss, US.
Gonsul-Generat; and Br." Etienne Lardy, Swiss Charge a'agaires (Adjournment Ordered) interesting summary of the beginnings of the Shanghai Municipal Council was given by Mr.
Bryan, Municipal Advocate, in' the Court of Consuls, on Oct. 7, when Chen Ling-sze and six other' plaintiffs brought a sult against the Council in regard to an. accident about 4am, on May 12 this year, when a motor car ran off the end of Yangtszepoo Road Into the Whangpoo River Canal, and seven men were drowned, Pisintifis represented them= selves as the widows and administrices of the estates of the deceased, and ere claiming different individual sums, amounting toa total of $188,- '734, in addition to the costs of the sult, on the grounds of negligence, the 'Council being accused of having falled to put a warning notice oF railing _at the end of Yangiszepoo Road." Sir John Brenan, Consul General for' Great Britain, presided at the hearing, accompanied by Mr.
Gauss, Consul-General for the United States, and M. Etienne Lardy, Swiss Charge Affaires. Plaintifts were represented by Mr. H. D. Rodger.
Called to give evidence, the Commissioner of Public Works, Mr. A. Gimson, identified a plan showing the geene of the accident and the surrounding Jand, and said the jetly over which the car plunged was a landing wharf" belonging to the Munlelpal Council. In 1928, the Council leased two-thirds of it to three all companies for facilitating the landing of gasoline. This lease had expired, and the wharf now was used chiefly for landing and storing material for the use of the Public Works Department.
'The plot of which the wharf formed a part never had been dedicated Yo the use of the public, as was the ase with the adjoining plot. Yang: tszepoo Road did not terminate at the Tanding wharf, and there was no road cading from' Yangtszepoo Road to}
pened. A plan for the construction the Jetty where the, accident apof such a road was drawn up in Yo8, but had never been carried out. As far as he knew, there had never been a similar accident at this spot, and there were a number of similar laces in the settlement, Responsibility of 8.0.0.
Opening the case for the plaintits, Mr, Rodger quoted the law an setting out that a municipality was charged With the care of Its streets, and was Fequited to exorcise reasonable care to. keep its streets in a safe condltion for travel, and to keep them free from such obstructions excavations as would be likely to Yender their use hazardous to one exercising due care, He quoted British and American law at length on the question of the nature and grounds of liability of a municipal Corporation, notice to the Council fan the alleged unsafe condition the rood, contributory negligence, ana other aspectsiot the case. Where 'a'munielpality had undertaken the the roads, he said, it was sponsible for exercising such care would prevent accidents that were avoidable.
Tu support of this view, Mr. Rodger referred to the Feetham report with Yegard to roads in the Settlement. In Volume 1 of the Land Regulations, it! was set out that the ratepayers should have certain powers with Yegard (o the purchase of land lead~ me. outside the Settlement for the construction of new roads. The Shanghai Municipal Council had authority to collect taxes for the pur-pote of keeping the roads in repair, and for other municipal functions. Where It had that authority, it had a corresponding liability, which was to Keep the roads in a safe condition for the use of the public. If it was necessary to erect barriers, the Coun-failed (0 do so, and if someone Was Injured as a result, the S.M.C. were lable,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.