The Archive · 1936

NEEDLESS MYSTERY

Oct, 20.

'The Shanghai Munteipal Council is assured of the ratepayers' support as it grapples with the difficult economic problems of the moment Us retrenchment programme may be said generally to have the mandate"of the electors, on the assumption, of course, that it be carried out with proper investiga tion of the relevant facts in the customary way of official procedure and in a spirit of equity and fairplay. 'There are signs, however, that the Council is not' effectively {in touch "with public opinion on certain points. A correspondent whose standing in the community is high but who is compelled by quite creditable reasons to vell his identity under a pseudonym has! drawn attention to the misapprehensions created by the reticence of the Council on, the resignation of the Into Secretary.. Tt will at once be appreciated that the relations between the Council and its high officers are delicate and demand discretion in treatment when disclosure to the public is in question Nevertheless it is impossible for the Council to. blink the fact that the reports to which the correspondent referred have caused considerable discussion, 'This journal is con-vineed that the Council has pro-eyeded to liquidate its obligations tots late employee with due regard to the ratepayers' interests and the services thus brought to an end at that oticer's request: The financial effect of the arrangement made may be eventually shown—in part at all events—in the annual budget Agures. There is nothing to prevent a ratepayer putting a precise question at the annual meeting. Yet the Council would surely be better advised to make some earlier specie statement when, as the lotter published showed, so much speculation detrimental to the confidence which should exist between it and the ratepayers is finding active indulgence. To the Council, no doubt, there mystery; but'to the public that conclusion is not 60 obvious, 'What are the Imown facts on which these' speculations are fastened? Lot them be briefly recapitulated. In March last the annual lection had to be annulled owing to an accidental failure to count 829 voting papers found in a ballot box on the day after what was thought to be the poll had been duly declared, 'The frst official announcement' issued from the Secretariat seemed to be inadequate asit was interpreted as. throwing the blame mainly on the nonofficial scrutineers. The Council appointed a committee of inquiry the report of which eventually apportioned the blame among two oflclals and. the two scrutineers.

This report was published on April 9. On May 15—to the surprise of many people—the Couneit's Gazette reproduced copies of identic letters addressed by the Chafrman to the two officials concerned of whom the Secretary was one. The letter conveyed the Council's opinion that the miscount was due in part to the negligence" of those two offldals, that it could not be ignored and "must therefore incur the disapproval and censure of the Coun-Making all allowances for the Council's political dimeulties it was felt surprising that a step of this kind was taken. Administrations having to take less than ex treme disciplinary action with po: manent officials do not go such lengths as to pillory them inthe official gazette, Almost exactly three months later the Gazette contained the intimation of the resignation of Mr. J. R. Jones, the Secre-tay in question, and a copy of a letter in which the Chairman very properly accepted that resignation and put on record "high appreciation of the ability and efficiency" with which he had discharged his duties to the Council "over.a Dut it was understood that he had decided to return to private practice fat the bar—as the event condrmed.

was not possible. to aszoclate 'Mr, Jones' decision with the ballot! box episode, although sympathy with him over the gazetting of the letter of censure undoubtedly. ed to the fooling that if he had re~ signed in resentment at that treat~ ment, it would not have been surprising. "On Sept 24 on the eve of his retirement he was entertained by the Council and in the presence of its Members and senior officials hho received a warm tribute and eulogy the purport of which was gonvered tothe pres for pubieg-

Decencles of convention must always be respected and in view of the known excellence of Mr. Jones! work, no Feasonable critic can davit at the Councils desire to make the parling as amicable' as possible. There is, however, such a thing as gilding the lly. On May 14, the Gouneit is moved to take an exceptionally expressive means for publicly intimating its "disapproval and censure" of Mr. Jones On Sept. 24, when he has resigned for personal reasons, it. goes out of its Way to reinforce the formal accept lance of his resignation with @ com= plimentary entertainment garnished exceedingly complimentary speeches which by semi-official clrculation to the press are apparently Intended to be marked and digested. No announcement is made regard~ ing the terms of the retirement, but, fs the: recently published letter Shows, various versions ud. ctr~ reney'in the course of social and other contacts subsequent to the event. "No wonder the public feels perturbed' and mystified. This Journal is convinced—as it "has already stated—that the Council' action has been governed by con com for the ratepayers' Interests fud for the reputation of the ser~ vices at its disposal, but the fact remains that the mention of certain figures without any official guide their significance or "ace curacy has aroused misapprehensions and a certain. degree. of anxiety which can only be dispelled by' some form of authoritative explanation. It is recognized that the Council has to take into consideration political "and. other delicate factors in dearing with its Sal problems, but as the rate payers are being asked to rely on. ils processes of financial adjustment in the light of an exceptionally crile stringency, they not unnaturally feel that frankness is an all-important begetter of the cent dence demanded of them. -The Council might therefore note that this bewilderment 1s not kely be allayed by the prospect of ultimately" discovering the relevant financial facts at the annual meeting as the result of a chance inter-ramation bya ratepayer to whom: an equally fortuitous answer may or may not be given,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account