The Archive · 1930

The Rubber Crash

Sept. 17, Shanghai is likely to see a number of rubber companies crash within the coming months unless some miracle saves them. The others will probably have a particularly trying time, and then only thanks to the financial reserves which have been built up will it be possible for them to weather the storm, This is no light matter for Shanghai, for there have been years when income from this source alone amounted to Tls. 6,000,000, and that—the greater part of a million pounds at the rate to which the port was accustomed until silver became thoroughly sick—is an item not easily replaced. Companies are told that they must rationalize—this by the economists—and they wonder what it all means, Management expenses have been cut down to a minimum and only by the grouping of estates in close proximity could it be possible to reduce these management expenses further than has already taken place. Whether it would then be economical is open to doubt, as so much has already been done in this direction, and all the advice received leaves the future still in a state of the greatest uncertainty. A foehn: of relief, it may be remembered, was experienced in London a cording to the telegrams received, when it was announced that Sir Cecil Clementi stated that on behalf of Malaya he would not agree to any official measure of restriction. There was, perhaps, the idea that Britain would again commit the Straits toa scheme in which the Dutch East Indies did not participate, and the fact that this was not so may have helped matters. It is more likely, however, that the relief was because the big companies with financial resources saw their hope for the future in the elimination of the smaller.

Tt is just as well that the worst should be known, In Singapore currency rubber is selling now at about twelve cents a pound, and it so happens that the best situated plantation companies can tap and undertake all the necessary processes incidental to marketing at this figure. That being the case it will certainly not pay them to suspend production, for they are enabled to keep their labour staffs together and the loss they incur in other ways is not nearly serious as were they to shut down altogether. In the circumstances there will necessarily still be a big. output of rubber produced at unremunera~ tive figures, and the surplus stocks will not have much chance of being worked off, in view of the smaller consumption in the tyre industry which is practically the only one that counts where rubber is concerned. And with tyres in the United States being sold at ever lower rates a revival in raw rubber prices must of necessity be remote, especially in view of the fact that one opinion is that there is six months' stock of the crude article. Were there a cessation of output or a handsome measure of restriction that stock, even in the present condition of world trade depression, might be expected to decrease substantially, but can we look for anything of that sort in the present state of the industry? It is more likely that all estates will go on tapping until they come under the auctioneer's hammer-when they may go out of business—and only then will tne companies with small production costs and large financial reserves be able to visualize a future not unacquainted with the prosper ity of the past.

Before that happens, however, other factors may have entered into the case. While large and well-organized plantation companies can market their product at a price of twelve cents a pound, it is not to be imagined that the Java native planter is in a similarly happy position. In the past the Dutch Government has not been able to bring much pressure to bear on the native planters in the East Indies—an independent, hard working set of people—but now the position may be that it will be the native planters who will have to ask the Dutch Government to take action on their be half. They have not the financial resources to keep things going as have many of the foreign companies, and one thing is certain, that none of the governments of the countries concerned will view with equanimity the prospect of two or three millions of men out of employment in their midst. The repatriation of Indians who have found lucrative employment on rubber estates would no doubt be satisfactorily tackled by the elaborate machin ery set up for that purpose by the government of India, It would, however, be a problem of some weight. The position of the native planter in Java andthe—_unemployment question may in the comparatively near—future prove to be very important factors in the rubber situation, and they are not to be ignored in any estimate of the situation. Rubber will probably only advance in price when a definite change in the world trade situation sets in, and from its present level it has to go a very long way before it becomes a hopeful commercial medium, but there is just this feature in the cas which may cause extraneot factors to operate for the betterment of its position,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account