The Archive · 1925

Gilding the Scoundrel

Not to do Dr. Hodgkin any injustice, it ought to be remarked that is an unaccountable streak aoost historians, even of front rank, hat, when limning out the charac. ters' of the outstanding scoundrels of history, they lovingly insist upon certain' sweet apitrcachableness, an incomparable social charm, or even. some marked feature of per-conal piety, in the private virtues of these dark misanthropes, which held to atone in some mysterious way for their masterful public eri-ames, and to redeem their memory from complete execration. The pagan inguisitors of Marcus Aurelius, the sack of Magdeburg in the 30 Years' War by Count Tilly, the' stakes and scaffolds of Bloody Mary, tthe horrors of Lenin's Cheka prisons, and the fiery massacre of Saikwan by Bun Yat-sen, are all mere moral tion with the philosophical theorems, the religious devotion, the stomachic revulsion from bloodshed, the social sweetness, and the last unctions of expiring piety, which respectively Jcharacterize those five self-certified Jand blundering vivisectors of hupr Ban in the artsle under nati I pass by two manifest libels on

[that to him, in the pursuit of objectives, his own "life was a small matter" and that "the sorrows of [the people were his sorrows," and T Jcome to the amazing statement that the characteristics seen in these leaders (Lenin and Sun) are among: those we value most highly in the. personality of Jesus Christ." To be fair, owr modernist guide is probably speaking here only of the s9- I qualities and personal magnet tisms emanating from those fine gifts of talk which his hero possessed in such marked degree, and which he calls "the noble qualities exhibited in his personality." But is my friend quite sure that he reetly compares him with the Sa-Jviour of men even here? Was Jezus Christ what might be called a social success? What about those strange breaches of dining-hall propriety in }the home of Simon the Pharisee; [those merciless and scathing re-Jjoinders on the day of questions, culminating in the seven damna-[tions huied against the leaders of contemporary society in Matthew 237 Did not such breaches of prepriety at last provoke those very social leaders to the terrible cry: Away! Crueify!" In fact, while in the chief monsters of history we sce! Jo fatal social magnetism joined to megalo-mania for wholesale homi-Jeide, we see precisely opposite chi [eetetisties in the Divine Savio Exemplar, whose recorded publ higo was a remarkable combination lof deliberate contempt for insincere feselal proprieties, joined to the ftenderest_merey and most self-sa-Jerificing concern for the true wel-fave of mankind, If Jesus Christ had met Sun Yat-sen on the eve of the Saikwan horror, would not the [Cantonese leader have talked glibly: Jabout the necessity of fire from heaven to curb those immortal Merchant Volunteers, and would not the Saviour have replied with words.

imilar to those used long ago: Thou knowest not what manner of spirit then are of!"

But how does Dr. Hodgkin really: arrive at the gushing gallery-play imported into this ar-He is talking to a Chinese [church but recently won from heat' Jenism, and codden through with Kuomingtang propaganda on the Chinese Soviet leader. His modern-{st principles do not allow him to speak his real mind, if indeed it is Jdifferent to what we find here. Instead, those principles enjoin him to Jmake' use of every possible "point Jof contact" and "ground of appeal" lby which he can conceivably app) Jmate his message to the thinking Jof the Chinese. He must "become all things to all men," an invoker of Jostentatious benediction on the athetst Lenin, and a pious Bolsheviet to the sychophantic mourners for Sun Yat-sen. In short, he rust tempora larily accommodate his __teach-jing to current Chinese be-chiefs," as he would allege is' Master did before him th the Jews of His time. And if whole-hearted revulsion from pseu-Ido-Marxism should tomorrow seize [the Chinese nation, and lead them to recall the Manchus, the same principles would lead Dr. Hodgkin to. print next month in the same organ, jo stirring eulogy of Tartar monfarchism and the Christian graces ciple—compliance the current]

Yi. For this is modernist prin-

trend, that, on Jsave some Inity ostentatiously plastered over things and all men. But all that [the poor world will get out of it in the long run will be a Kingdom of heaven in which the twelve fruits Jof the Tree of life shall make mad the eaters, and the crystal river itself shall turn into blood.

For modernism is not a revolving Hiantern, throwing a measured bean: from the light-house of Christi truth for the guidance of storm. tossed nations. It is only a revolving. weather-cock which, though obedient: to every blast of the typhoon, will Met even crow when Peter denies his Lord, or the recognized high-priests lof religion demand His re-crucifixion the very house of His friends.

Iam, ete,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account