The Archive · 1936

A Definite Fallacy

"I propose to deal with my. argue ment. inthe Inverse order to Mr. MoNell commenced Mr. Newmat pel haps your Lordship will not be so interested in my arguments on the you were not satisfied riot a definite fallacy in my learned, friend's last "argument, He has endeavoured to convince your fact, there was no The Court had heard from the evidence before It that the defendant company come into being through two sources, Artesian Wells, Ltd., and the plaintiff company. "Artesian Wells equipment came into the company al valuation of about 'Tls. 41,600, the Plaintiffs at 'Tis, 69,000;" these' two added together to a total of Tls. 129,600, which was the stock list value of the new company.

addition, they had been told there were certain purchases, and after going through the evidence, he Placed the value of these at a cone of Tis, 23,000 at the most, He was prepared to concede that Tis, 3,000 should be added to the figure for materials returned to slock and not listed. The book value the company's slock amounted to The actual value of stock. owned, however, was about Tls. 253,000; deducting about Tis,.48411_ for Intiation, they had Tls. 207,575 which, Jess the book value, was approximates ly Tis, 28,5096, That last figure could only be the value of articles over~ Gelivered. "It was dim cult to assess reso. Agures "accurately, but, the fi ference. was between "is," 20000 snd Tis, 38000, and the actual fixing the- amount could be Jeff to an STR ud. tht you have sulfeced damages" commented "his Lordship,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account