The Archive · 1937

Was Unjustified

JUDGMENT GIVEN FOR PLAINTIFF

Claiming $5,000 as damages, Dr. Carl Foss, owner of the China X-ray Ca, appeared in the French Consular Court yesterday as plaintiff in|. a case against the Cercle Sportif Judge Rivelain Kaufman, and M. Ladroitte and Casson-Bonardel, sitting Әs assessors. Counsel were M. Paul Premet, for plaintiff and M. de Goth, for defendants.

Dr. Foss claimed that the committee of the French Club had not sufficient grounds to apply to him Article 36 of the Club's rules, pro-Yiding that "should a member con-suspended.

The decision of the committee should not have been publish-td as had been done, as such publication was not provided for by the rules. Plaintiff also demanded that he be reinstated in his membership With all privileges and rights, an that the judgment be published.

The facts of the case as stated were that by letter dated April 12, 1937, Dr. Foss complained to the secretary Of the Club concerning the inefficiency of the service of the club. On April 16, the committee replied above the signature of the secretary that "the committee refused to accapi the terms of Mr. Carl Foss's letters, requesting him to withdraw thesame and apologize for having

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account