Nov. 4.
Judge Penrhyn Grant Jones has' rendered a' valuable service in drawing pointed attention to the unsatisfactory state of the law
British, Companies. locating to the rostration remembered that "last Registrar of Companies pros a certain company. under Article 104 (2) of the'. China Order-in-'Council: 1925, for what appeared, recording: to' Counsel, to be:"an obvious abuse of the judicial and diplomatic. protection accorded British persons. in China. 'The argument was that as the bulk of the shares were in -non-British hands the British control preseritied by the Order-in-Council for British registration' was non-existent, The case,.was, heard in. HM. Police Court. and the Magistrate, in giving a reserved judgment, acquitted the accused on the ground that the non-British "ownership, of the majority of the shares was not iMiclent to prove that the law as:
stood had been broken, appeal against: this judgment was lodged—a testimony to the cogency of the learned. Magistrate's ruling and; in the elreumstances admitted in Court, to the unsatisfactory dratting of the Order-in-Council.: This journal took the view that the. law Yequired amendment for apart from other considerations, the existence of the system of extraterritorial jurisdiction made it damaging to Jogitimate; rights under that: system if a.practice could grow up to: bérmit the nationals, of Utopia, bby assuming the, status of Laputans, to.do certain things im 6 them og-Utopl Later:-this. plea for' amendment, of [the -Order-in-Couneil "was: reinforced at some length in a leading article which reviewed the. facts of that. particular case and urged that the' necessary" amendment should not be very difficult to effect, Although it was recognized that such action might cause hardship in certain special cases, it was, pointed out that the existence of a loophole which permitted other concerns to obtain the cover of law for activities meriting no appro. whatsoever, was the real issue at stake, Elimination of. that loophole was therefore highly desirable, the -Newmilks case which came before Judge Grant Jones the British character of the company was not in dispute. Nor were the circumstances generally cotnparable with those of the case heard by 'Mr, 'C; H.. Haines last year in the) Police Court," The Judge had to cal with a claim by an employee for the balance of his salary. The two cases find common ground in. that the Magistrate held that' the non-British ownership of the majority of a company's shares wa not necessarily a bar to registration og a British company. The Judge, eliciting the fact that of 10,065 shares all save the odd 65 were held by non-British interests, expressed the view that it was an encroachment on the "privileges granted to British subjects by treaty with the authorities of this country" that such accompany should be allowed to "masquerade as British." The Judge was, of course, not impugr~ ing the action of the Registrar of Companies in the exercise of Jing" company was registered, for functions whereby the
obviously the Magistrate's judgment had shown that the Registrar had no other course, as the Order-in-Council stood, The importance of the Judge's forceful obiter dictum lies in the fact that it authoritatively draws the British Government's attention to an abuse of the law which the local British authorities them~ selves, as' shown by the unsuccess~ {ul prosecution last year, considered to be in need of redress, It Is preposterous that the time of British' officials~should be Scuvied in settling often intricate points of law and hearing voluble arguments, at the expense of the British taxpayer when the company concerned derives its right to those benefits by what cannot, be described more fittingly than. by' Judge Grant Jones when he called ita masquerade, It raises, too, other no less serious issues. The privilege of extraterritoriality which British subjects enjoy by. treaty. between their Government and the Government of China Is highly esteemed. British policy, especially in recent years, has been to scrutinize! severely the exercise of that privilege lest it should, unwittingly deliberately, be used as a cover! o the operations of other nationals for whose personal actions it is im= possible for the British Government, to take responsibility. It is common knowledge that steps have from time to time been taken to stamp out such abuses when brought to light. Happily for the: Sood name of Great Britain they' are not-frequent. Yet it is obvious that when a company, whose British registration is a mere "masquerade" or camouflage made possible by a Toosely drafted Order-in-Counelt, can $0 avail itself of British' services, the opportunity for abuses derogatory to British honour is wide open. "This of course does not, convey any criticism of the operations of either of the two companies involved in the cases which have brought the anomaly to light.
merely seeks to emphasize the extremely proper objections which the Court has raised to the looseness of the law governing British registration, Judge Grant Jones would be quite as justified to cavil the obligation to investigate the! delinquencies of some other company registered in such terms, as was, in the case under mention, toj resent the encroachment on British privileges involved in his' being called upon to settle a civil Aispute between an employee and company which was British in ownership by virtue of 65 shares of. a total of 10,065 allotted to its shareholders. It Is greatly to be hoped that "the judictat criticism will be brought to the notice of the authorities competent to make the requisite redrafting.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.