The Archive · 1926

Some Criticisms and a Critic

Jan.

'Tiere was: an American' gentleman who once remarked that the inventor of "near beer" was 'a poor judge of distance, ud, if we may say so, Allan's description, in the corres-Pondence columns to-day, of our leader on "Justice Finley Johi son's Obiter Dicta," as "vit betrays a lack of proper appreciation of acidity. We venture to differ from our correspondent in that particular mat ter, and to offer the suggestion that, not only did we say whi we had to say with all due re-

"spect to the Tearned jurist's erudition, but that we differed from him only on the point of what we consider to be his excussion outside the terms of the commission which brought him to inquire into the disturbances of 'May 90. We have no desire to raise' amy question as to. any finding of the American Judge. so far as it may properly be said to come within the terms of his commission, Whatever he said in that respect was absolutely his right; and, while everyone may not share his opinion, no one would dream of questioning his sincerity. But we believe at we are entitled to point out, where the judge has gone outside the limits set him in his commission and indulged in obiter dicta, which, however interesting they may be from an entirely different point of view, should find no Lace in a report arising from a judicial inquiry, the scope of which was wide enough in all]

Mr. Allan must know that.in 4 court of law administering an Anglo-Saxon code, the scope of quiry is strictly limited by he pleadings, especially where the code takes so much trouble to limit those pleadings to the real point at issue, Mr, Allan must know that, if the judge admits evidence not relevant to the issue, f his finding goes outside the pleadings or the record, that decision is open to revision by higher tribunal, and possibly to very severe criticism. Conquently when we find that Judge Jolson has thought fit to express opinions on subjects which did not come within the roope of the inquiry he was asked to make, we believe that our iricism is justified. How can it be argued that the question of the rendition of the Mixed Court properly came within the (arns of reference, or that the question of extraterritoriality was one which could properly be discussed in an investigation into a riot? How is it possible to believe that sufficient evidence on these points was given before the Commission to justify any such Dronouncerients? If there were not sufficient evidence, and in Foint of fact there was not—for [either of these questions needs commission for itself alone—then we are driven to the ce clusion that not only was Justice Johnson going outside the scope his commission in pronouneing upon them, but that he was also off the record taken before him. And as Mr. Allan knows, no judge should do We do not for a moment fear hat our criticism of Judge Johnson will engender any bad blood between the two English-speak-Ing peopl of this or any other} community. It is certain tha: the interests of neither are served by a servile suppression of comment, True harmony can only come from a frank express sion of view, and it would be puerile to suggest otherwise.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account