approved records of the addresses seven to its members in private meet Ing in accordance with the scheme recently established for the study marlers of general interest. INF, Arnholé's exposition of the finances the Shanghai Municipal Council had the merit of topicality and Believed to have made a good. Impression on his audience. He gave a clear and convincing account of the financial difficulties with which the Couneit is confronted and thereby reinforced arguments for the obser and prudent ents. Tt will be noted that subsequently Mr. Arnhold had to correct certain' misapprehensions which his reference to the relations of the heads of departments to the Eeonomy Report had created, There is no. need therefore for this journal te modify its criticisms on that aspect of the Committee's. work, For the rest, Mr. Arnhold's champ ship of at feast one member of the Couneit's permanent stall is welcome; hitherto—did modesty not ferbid—it might have been thought that the duty of expounding the importance of preserving the traditions of a sound permanent civil service and, con= sequently, of rebutting certain' views, which apparently have had some in-nonce on the Economy Committee, had been left entirely to this journal, Mr, Arnholt's speech revealed 1 study of the Press hax Jed him to encounter newspapers. to which the eneral public does not seem to have find access. However, there will be no disposition to envy him on that
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.