The Archive · 1936

By SAPAJOU

wise good intentions, 'This has} found vivid reflection in the' resultant report. So, in avoiding the Scylla of expensive dilatoriness, the Council has been drawn into the Charybdis of breathless and, ultimately perhaps, no less extravagant haste. The report itself is a peculiar document. -Usually a Committee charged with such a mission as that imposed on the three axe-wielders, considers it pertinent and, indeed, necessary for its justification, to explain the methods of procedure adopted, the kind of evidence taken andthe line on which the inquiry was developed, Except for a reference to the number of meetings held—which has led enthusiastic, if naive, critic to invite the world to admire the impressive spectacle of busy men' devoting themselves to work for; which they sought the suffrages of the ratepayers—and an unconvineing assertion that certain essential data could not be secured for want of time, the public is completely in the dark. The Committee appears to be blissfully unconscious that the Report has thus set up a record for reticence which, if adopted by other administrations, might save a printing bill but would enormously decrease the number of fruitful investigations, Perhaps it may be useful to outline the kind of procedure which experience in other countries is prone to prescribe for instruments of inquiry. The Commission or Committee or Tribunal is given a permanent oMfcial of standing—not always the head of a department—and on him is laid the burden of preparing the ground. In. an inquiry such as that under report, the official would probably be a senior member of the Finance Department. "His first task is to prepare a questionnaire which is circulated to the various departments and on receipt of the replies he is thus able to draft some preliminary memorandum for the guidance of his Committee. This may have been the method by which the Council's three heroes: proceeded, but no evidence is forthcoming to justify that view. Indeed it is reliably asserted that the Heads of Departments were not the newly appointed Secretary could fairly be expected to fulfil these requirements, At any rate no attempt is made by the Report to establish that thesis. In these days it sounds fashionable to adopt the dictatorial pose which affects to tell the public go hang and the Press, endeavouring to act as the public's humble interpreter, to go even further. If the Cotnell is aurider the delusion that it can adopt this fashion with any satis~ faction. to its constituents, the sooner it recovers from ' that amiable state of pathological infirmity the better. It does not seem fo realize that it can com= mand whole-hearted and by no means ungenerous support it it fearlessly takes the electorate. into its confidence as it has 30 often promised to do, There is far too much talk of the need of secrecy lest the Litiputians or the Brobdingnagians get to hear what usually Teaks out through those very sources, possibly in garbled guise, but inevitably to the discomfiture of the Sphinxes., Lately, the Council, after much persuasion' by careful midwifery, gave birth to an explanation of its. remarkable adjustment of the Secretariat staff, Obviously, in certain respects, it was blameless, for it was bound by the actions of' one of its predecessors, Yet that predecessor must have acted under advice and surely fitting, in view of the im-Portance of the issue, to know whether due note has' been made for future guidance, Often the Council is remiss in exposing its senior oMelals to public criticism for decisions which should be announced in the Council's name and on the Council's responsibility. Again, it seems to have tone to the other extreme in Handling problems which have aroused considerable controversy and uneasiness. Whatever may be the defects of the Economy Report, they do not bring the Council strictly within the peril of censure as its apparent condonation of the evasion of responsibility where such facts, as have been allowed to escape from the close confinement of a timorous secretiveness, plainly prescribe responsibility to be borne. Pontius Pilate may have been an excellent politician; he would not have made a satisfactory municipal servant.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account