The Archive · 1936

Cases Cited

The first was the ease of Joseph Thompson, reported in the "North-China Herald," Jan.-Mar., 1916, page G0, in which the Judge" (Sir itaviland @—Sausmarez) said that British protected, person was to be treated as a British subject". th the ease of Rex v. Crank, reporied in the (NAE, Herald." Oct-Dec, 1914, pare 453, Havilland held that, although a British subject, he apparently was 1 as such, and that was suflleient, for the Cotirt to pass sentenc> on him. Mr. Potter also quoted briefly from Sept. page 395, Ex going on to quote from a judgment given by. Full Court in a ease wh judgment read in part—

"Now the Order in Council 1035, was enactment contained in any article Order in Gounell cannot be gpuct made by" virile oth Goutal ta in the same passion: submit that at the moment." Potter went on: "I have not come to own case yet. Ihave been dealing with my learned friend's. The posi tion is that, if a person is a British subject, and has been made such, he must be dealt with by the Order-in-Council as a British subject throughout. If nothing in the Order-én-Council preserves for him a. partly cular branch of law—for_ instance, Tragian law—there is nothing to do except to apply internal English lay. submit there was nothing to show the deceased was anything but a British subject."

Questions involving the correct application of the China Order-in-Council involving property in China and emphasizing the Impossibility of applying Chinese law. to British protected persons were put by Mr. Potter, on Dec. 3, during the continued hearing of the ease.

Mr. Potter opened the day's hearing by saying he wanted to. know what exactly was Mr, Reader Hortis* argument. "From a. shorthand note taken at the time, it would appear it was twofold; firstly, that the Court could not go outside the treaty with China and, secondly, that the only Jaw that mattered was the law of domicile, Plaintif's point of view seemed to be that the British Government had no tight to legislate In the case of protected persons such as the late Mr, Hardoon, "Law of the Site"

Mr, Reader Harris had entirely Gisregarded the law of the site, although this applied to immovable property (andthe estate was about 905 per cent, immovable property, fu' the form of perpetual leases). Why he bald no attention to it, he GINE, "Potter) "could not fathom, especially when there was a specific article in the Order-in-Council whic he would submit was literally the Jaw of the site, It was one of the most important points in the whole ease, and he failed to see why counsel for the. plaintiff had neglected it.

The Judge said this probably was because Mr, Reader Harris relied on the law of domicile, and not site, and $0 proposed dealing with the latter In his summing-up.

'Mr, Potter pointed out that, since practically the whole of the' estate Was perpetual leasehold property, which only could be dealt with by the law of the site, this means plain" UM's case would have to go out of Court. He quoted a number of auithorities in support of his contention, The Judge, summing up Mr. Potter's argument at this stage, said it was the effect that Article 115 Inovitably Involves the law of the site.

Mr. Potter agreed, and said it was part of the law the governing power of the country allowed to be admit ted. "Article 104 read:—"Subject. to the provisions of this Order, the clvit Jurisdiction of every Court acting under this Order shall, as far as clreumstanees admit, be exercised in the principles of, and in conformity: with, English law for the time being in force:" Article 115. read:—"AlL real_or immovable property: situate China, belonging at the Gme his dea'h'to any British subject dyin after tne commencement of this Order, shall be deemed to be personal estate, "and. the devolution thereof, ease of intestacy, shall be regu lated according to the law of England for the time being relating (o per= sonal estate, the High Road"

Where the term "English Jaw" in the first implied the whole of the law of England, it only meant the internat law of England in the second, "That.

the high road through this cas The Judye—Do you, then, take the igh road and att Header Hans the Poller—t think Me. ares thinks 1 take a very low road!

'On the question of whether or not China could make laws that were binding on British subjects, Mr. Potter said he did not think it' could bbe contended that China had the right to impose such laws without the consent of the powers concerned, 'The Judje agreed, and said thix applied tu the ease of, say, the income lax Taw coming into' effect. Chinese could only be imposed British subject if It way covered by the King's Regulations, Regarding Mr. Reader Harris" point that the Court could nut affect the personal status, such as the right fof succession of protected persons, because that would be a derogation of the power of China, Mr. Potter Asked If it Were not a greater derogation to deal with a man's. pei Sonal' tibetts, as He M. Supreme Court had done in the past. Foreign countries. always were especially Jealous of the rights of a man's Liberty, and much more jealous than thes were of the question of success sion. There was no comparison between the two, and it could not be denied that the Court had handled some very important questions personal liberty in the past.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account