The Archive · 1930

FILM CENSORSHIP

Oct. 8.

From time to time the question of the censorship of films becomes a topic of interest the community at large. In Shanghai, which is no mean patron of the film industry, and which boasts a most eosin: politan film public, it is surer ing that the arduous task of passing films for production is performed with so little inconvenience to the industry and to the public which maintains that industry. No doubt the managers of the cinema theatres themselves would profess to be sometimes a little incommoded by the necessity for displaying their long expected treasures to a few critical dignitaries of the Shanghai administration, but, so far as can be judged, there is an abundance of good feeling on both sides. This should be accounted to the credit of the film censors, who obviously have. considerable power of dislocate ing the best laid plans of the cinema manager. An interesting sidelight on this aspect of. censorship is revealed in a report of the Colonial Films Committee, as presented to Parliament last July. The presentation of undesirable films to the aboriginal inhabitants of outlying colonial districts came under the consideration of thi committee, and it was discovered that one of the obstacles in' the way of a satisfactory censorship lay in the dilemma to which the censor might expose the local cinema manager in the event of being compelled completely to ban the film. The Report says: "In some cases "the official responsible for ce "soring the film has been put in "the position that if he did not "pass films which he felt to be "unsatisfactory the cinema pro-"prietor would have to close, "down, as there was nothing else "to show." This predicament could not readily occur in so important a cinema centre as Shanghai, for it may be suspected that the enterprising cinema manager keeps up his sleeve, as were, a sufficient number of, spare films to permit the censor On one aspect of censorship there. often seems to be some confusion of thought. The mere fact that a film inaccurately portrays the normal life of an individual class, or of an individual nation, is not sufficient to justify the contention that it should be subject to the censor's emendation or prohibition. If inaccuracy were a crime on the part of the scenario writer, no plays would ever be produced, although it is to be hoped that, cinema producers are just as keen on getting accurate local colouring as any of their colleagues dealing with the legi mate stage. The British Board of Film Censors has issued a pamphlet indicating the lines on which that body does its work in Great Britain, and the pamphlet gives a list of tendencies and subjects which are definitely treated to the expurgatory order. The principle by which the Board is guided is to pass nothing which is calculated "to "demoralise the public, extenuate "crime or vice, or shock just "susceptibilities of any section "of the public." The conclusion, therefore, is that each film is treated on its individual merits, and the composition of the average audiences is taken into account, such audiences being] held to include "a not incon-"siderable portion of people of "immature judgment." That the operation of this principle has confronted the Board h knotty problems for solution is plain, as the pamphlet shows that the Board has to repudiate the idea that because a story is published in literary form it is necessarily suitable for the screen, And the tricks of tain producers have to be inva tigated, such as, for example, the presentation of a perfectly inoffensive film under a title known to be that of a notoriously improper book. Then again, the Board considers the difference in psychological impression as produced by the printed word and the optical presentation on the film, All of which goes td show that film censorship has become very much a matter of expert treatment, The critic ses the virtues or of a film in the newspaper would not necessarily be a good guide to its censorship for production.

There is one danger into which the British Board of Censors does not seem likely to fall, but it is worth attention in a place like Shanghai, Much stress is so often laid on the influence of the cinema on Oriental minds, that it would: seem desirable to create a special form of censorship for films to be displayed in the East. The facts hardly Gear out this pessimistic view. Always presuming that the principles en-undated above are kept in mind, there is little less harm done by. cinema plays of the melodramatic type in the East than in the West. Indeed the cinema has brought to light the fundamental similarity of the human emotions. The London audience! which delights to see the daredevil cavalier extricate the beautiful heroine from an unimaginable disaster at the hands of the consistently evil villain is well supported by the audience in Shanghai or in Calcutta, There is no thought of creed colour or different standards of ization, it is the old ingrained human affection for a good story: simply told. "The play's the thing," says the audience, "and a plague on politics." If! cinema censors bear this point! well in mind they will be saved an enormous amount of trouble' and their be spared many sleepless nights.

Oct.

'The nominees of the Government, the Conservative Party, the 'Liberal Party, and the Government of India, to attend the Indian Conference have been'

gularly well chosen, On the Liberal and Conservative sides there is no one who hat identified himself with any extreme point of view, and there is sufficient practical experience of Indian conditions to justify, the suggestion that great assistance in expediting the dis cussions will be forthcoming, Of special interest will be the appearance of the Marquess of Reading, an ex-Viceroy, at the conference table, and hardly less noteworthy is the name of the Marquess of Zetland, who is strongly favoured as Lord Inwin's successor, and who was a most brilliant Governor of, Bengal as the Bari of Ronald—shay. Lord Zetland, besides being an able administrator, with extensive knowledge of Indian conditions, is an author of repute who' has managed in a marked degree to expound to his countrymen the philosophical subtleties of Bengali thoughc, Among the officials whose attendance at the conference is defined as "for consultative purposes," there is that exceedingly able Indian Civilian, Sir Mal-calm Bailey, who was the outstanding figure in Lord Reading's cabinet, has governed two provinces with conspicuous success, and is by far the most impressive figure in Indian official dom to-day. A brilliant speaker, with a keen intellect which has consistently kept itself abreast of world affairs, added to manner which his" critics have sometimes described as Curzon: ian, Sir Malcolm Hailey's pre sence should be of the utmost value to the conference. He will bring to it recent and practical knowledge of the task of coping. with the civil disobedience movement, for it was in his province " that the executive has had quarters, and it was by him that

unlawful assembly. An equally, the Congress was declared an@) strong personality, if lacking some of the special qualities: which have marked Sir Malcolm Hailey's career, is Sir Charlea Innes, the outspoken Governor of Burma, who will come to th conference with the satisfactory, knowledge that the separation: of Burma from India, which he himself has warmly advocated, will probably be carried, for th Simon Commission's recommend~ ation on that point can hardly be ignored. Sir Charles: Innes represents the British official who has almost a hereditary, connection with India, His father was a surgeon-general in that country, his grandfather Was a major-general in the army of the East India Company, and his second son to-day is serving in his father's own service. Sir Cecil MeWatters is a young Indian Civilian who has brilliantly served in the Finance Department and is an expert on currency and finance. 5

Another notable representative is the Marquess of Lothian, better known as Mr. Philip Kerr, who has established a reputation for vision and breadth of thought in the discussion of international problems, Sir Ro-. bert Hamilton is a retired Colonial civil servant of distinct tion, who has been an able; exponent of the views of the-.|, attenuated Liberal Party on. India in the present parliament. Sir Samuel Hoare, as Air Minister, made the personal ac-, quaintance of India, in the Cit; of Delhi aeroplane and warm adherent of Lord Irwin's policy, while Lord Peel, the last Conservative Secretary of State for India, is a man who has devoted much industry to ths

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account