The Archive · 1926

THE MOSUL DECISION!

OF the many people who, like the. heathen, have variously raged together over the question, of Mosul, and the wisdom or otherwise of Great Britain's commitments in Mesopotamia, it would be interesting to know} how many really understood the issues involved. When the announcement came from Geneva December 16 last that the League of Nations practically upheld the British contention against the Turks by deciding in favour of the "Brussels line." the numbers of those in any town of not less than ten thou zand people who could have said where the line ran or how Brussels came to be interested in it would probably have been a decimal. But the question of Mosul is not only one of political importance; it involves matters of high principle, and some notes, on the settlement may be acceptable. The excellent little map which we reproduce from the: "Times" with this article shows. the whole position at a glance.

The question of the Iraq frontier, where the dividing line was to be drawn between the old Turkish Empire and the nev Kingdom of Iraq, independent but under the protection of Great Britain, who had accepted responsibility for the country te} the League of Nations, was primarily one of defence. The collapse of Turkish power in these regions at the end of the war, left Great Britain the sole trustworthy. authority, with lively interest in defining the it of her duties and an equally vivid sense of duty to the people of Iraq. The mountains northward of the vilayet of Mosul were the obvious, as indeed the only natural, frontier; but to this the Turks, having an eye to the fertile country of the vilayet, would not agree. The Treaty of Lausanne left the matter open and it was eventually referred to the League of Nations, which, at a meeting held in Brussels in October, 1924, fixed upon the} line since called after this city, a purely provisional front pending t final decision on all gues, As will be seen, the' Brussels line does not go quite as far north as that claimed by} the British Government, who felt that protection should be givea 40 certain Christian communities, Assyrians and Govan Chaldeans, he sequel has shown that th feeling was thoroughly justified and it is to be regretted on humanitarian lines that the League of Nations has dri and finally fixed the frontier it has done, In September last the British Government appealed to the League to send a Commission to ascertain the truth gf certain grave incidents reported from the Brussels line, The Turkish Government also appealed for an investigation, not too from its own point of view, 2s subsequent events showed. Acting with unusual despatch, the League of Nations appointed an International Commission of five persons under General Laidoner so promptly that the investiga tors were actually at Bagdad by October 26 and had completed their report by the end of November, General Laidoner's sti ment is one of extraordinary interest. Written in the most terse and matter-of-fact style, it in-Aicates a tale of tragedy almost, comparable with the massacring of the Armenians by Turkey during the war. The first three items of his investigation General Laidoner dismisses fairly casu The tribal raids across the frontier in either direction, he says, cannot be regarded as exceptional in these wild mountain districts and the then unsettled state of the frontier naturally encouraged them. This last factor would also help to explain posts south of the Brussels line: General Laidoner thinks the local Turkish authorities now understand the position; at least there are no more Turkish outposts where they should not be. As for Turkey's complaint of British aeroplanes violating the frontier General Laidoner considers it based on misunderstanding. But as regards the maltreatment by the Turks and expulsion of Christians north of the Brussels me, there was neither error nor misunderstanding.

General Laidoner found in the district of Zakho some 3,000 deported Christians and every day isolated groups continue to arrive in Iraq. These refugees come from the villages situated in the zone between the Brussels line and the line claimed by the British Government; there are also som who have come from the. villages situated north of the latter line.

We italicize words which bear witness that the British line was not unadvisedly drawn, Great ame Treaty Frontiers Tittle map. shove cly the Issues vains were taken by Genet Laidoner and his colleagues in examining refugees and to get at them directly they entered Iraq in order to avoid any possibility of collusion, General Laidoner writes, and all his colleagues endorse what he says:—

"AIL the refugees' statements are im absolute agreement and may be summarized as follows: (1) Turkish wldiers, under the command of} oticers,' occupied the villages, and in the first place obtained dei of all the arms; they then imposed very heavy fines and demanded cen; they then pillaged the d subjected the inhabitants to atrocious acts of violence, going as far as massacre; (2) the deportations were deportations en masse,.and according to the statements made, the refugees were conducted to 8 district further removed from the provisional line. During the deport" Vons several persons fell ill on the way and were abandoned; others of starvation and cold, for, when they had to} 1g and were unable to carry with them either food or clothing.

"This is the general account given the depositions. We hi Christian refugees were constrain: Ly force and violence to leave th villages and their homes is to be found in the fact that they have arrived in Iraq without any means of subsistence.

"At the present time the situation of these people, in spite of the subsidies of the Iraq Government and the financial help of institutions and fate persons in England, is st Ceplorable. They have lost all their] It is practicably im-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account