The Archive · 1936

A Tragic Decision

Dec. 11.

Yesterday, exactly a week after the news of the disagreement be-over His Majesty's marriage project had been broken {o the British public by official announcements, Mr. Baldwin was to be charged with the heavy duty of communicating {o, Parliament the fateful decision of the King to abdicate.. The actual text of Mr, Baldwin's announcement, is not to hand, as these words are: written, but there can be hardly any; doubt that His Majesty has taken, the course which he regards as consistent with the requirements of the Empire and the dictates of his own sentiment. Unprecedented as the voluntary abdication of a British monarch is, the circumstances at. tending: this unhappy termination of what was hoped would be a success ful reign have aroused the deepest regret. There has been a virtually unanimous feeling of sympathy for the Prime Minister who, with excep tionally urgent cares on his shoulders, has been suddenly. confronted by a most dangerous crisis from a quarter where he had the Fight least to expect any lack of appreciation of the essential importance of the ce-operation of the Crown with the chief Government of the Empire. For many weeks, and his colleagues hav tackled this problem behind een of a wise but ever-in= creasingly difficult reticence which, it must sadly be confessed, the King appears to have done little to ease. When they could no longer withhold the facts from the public, was not really because the time had come to call for an expression of public opinion, for no argument had been omitted on either side in the course of the painful controversy as it emerged into view last week. In fact, although it has taken a week for the final decision to be made, judgment had in essence been passed the moment the deadlock was exposed to the country's gaze. The delay has been understandable and, indeed, has ministered to the national sense of caution and fairplay. Except for the vapourings of certain irresponsibles who have not been deterred by the existence of an imperial emergency from ex-plaiting the opportunity to ada to their petty notoriety, the Empire has been solidly behind the Cabinet as the significance of the constitutional issue unfolded itself.

For human sorrow there is always human sympathy: seldom is that sympathy more in need than by the man who has brought the snow on his own shoulders. On that ground alone the King is'assured of respectful sympathy—intensified as it will be by regret that many years of recognized service to the Empire thus are wasted in the void of poignant disappointment, For his leadership as Prince of Wales and, lately for all too short a time as King, the Empire tenders gratitude which now has to be tragically fulfilled in acceptance of his present decision. There is no call to enter into discussion of the project which produced the disagreement with his Ministers, It sufficient to note that on an affair of State, the King found himself, for personal reasons, unable to accept} the advice of his Ministers, The liberties of Great Britain and the Empire which has been founded on British institutions, derive directly from the constitutional principle thus at issue. "His Majesty had his right of appeal to the Nation, under the Constitution, but it has been made abundantly clear that that, would not have solved the problem, His Government thus represented the solid will of the people; that will has prevailed, as it has pre= vailed for over seven centuries of English history. Not without significance is the fact that ¢he faint ries of dissent have emanated chiefly from those people who, if they had their way, would destroy the parliamentary traditions which Great Britain has developed and, to-day, is maintaining with special fervour in a world of unrest and despair. It is astonishing, indeed, that a man, credited as the King! has been with a lively appreciation of the democratic instinct in his people, could have discerned any star outcome of hare:

when have aal fatally inspired him cannot be im~ pugned, for it is not open to any but the King himself to appraise: them, They have presented to him inescapable dilemma, No-one now will feel more deeply than he, in this hour of his travail, how relentless has been the force of tween the King and the Cabinet] the circumstances which his actions!t Was not sufficient for the Gov~ have set in train, It is earnestly hoped that he may find means, in due course, to retrieve his peace of mind, even though his kingly slate be gone. If human decisions bear the burden of irreparability, there is a higher instrument of ce! rection which can mitigate their woo. The King, indeed, first. step in hood by paying the price which his tortured sense of divided duty prescribed. From that he may be able to proceed in eventual readjustment of his life so that he need not be deprived of opportunities of service, albeit not those: once inherent in his destiny. His bdication will be hailed with deep regret, yet n thartfulness in view of the momentous issues a stake, To his royal Mother, the heart of the Empire goes out in this second bitter of a few short months. To his brother, who Hed upon to assume the thus discarded, sympathy—all the more lively because of the known affection between him and the King that also stretches out its hand, For the rest, the Empire has need to preserve the equanimity which con= issness of its strength and ity happily affords. Th essence the sad decision is taken for the Empire's sake. The Empire has rallied round the Government as the events of this tragic week haw made themselves manifest. It for yeth Empire and Government to see that the Throne is made secure, by their unswerving loyalty, for the duty the Empire in peace and integrity.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account