The Archive · 1936

MORTGAGE LAW A Chinese Defence

To the Béltor of the "Nosu-Cutna Datiy News!

Sin,—Coming as a direct answer to your correspondent C, N.S, R. who frilielzed severely the Mortgage Yaw, T'would ike to bring you forthwith my humble opinion in that respect.

Law in China, as well a3 in other states, is devoted to the general protection of Its"subjects especially those uffering from exceeding poverty, fand not, of course, particularly ends 'aL the safeguard of minor interests of riches. "It is. also' so meant. to maintain the constancy of a state that must. prohibit, the enjoyment of ownership of Jand'by foreigners save under necessity. This principle, being the low of China, prevails over everywhere within Chinese territory, excluding the Settlement in Shanghai and other ports oblaned by' treaty trid the estate owned by Missions Landholders in Shanghai, should, therefore, be quite satisfied with their special treatment granted by Chinese Government.

'What was mentioned by your cor respondent os: "old men and widows Wye invested their money. in' Mort-age ant that is the best security they could find in China" is obviously far from the truth and also not material to the point of issue, as there are many enterprises for' foreigners In Shanghai which are as good ax Morigoge, that is quite known and lear, man, "lao, therefore, woul wether Mortgage has beet well protected or not.

Chinese Jaw and the law of other states provided the similar recourse by bringing action against the other arty In case the Jatier has failed perform his duly, and T, as a law student, really wonder whether there any' better recourse other than litigation and. should beg your cor= respondent to suggest more effective and speedy way' other than asking for redress from court, has been further commented that there is practical impossibility of col-Jecting rents from. intransigeant tenants finds also'no support inthe 'Mortgage law now in force as well as ils Yang, successful, adrafrable practice, China shat "itis in thi' stale Of Your correspondent spoke yet of fairs which may make it impossible for even the most. well "meaning Mortgage to meet hiv duty." 'This mocking statement, that determined misunderstand Chino, has engaged thoroughly the malice' intention to hurt China generally, and Is therefore, Rot worthy to pay any attention, but I really "doubt why your" cor respondent forgot to say that it is only this slate that foreigners could enjoy so much rights which other states could never allow?

As a result of the discussion, 1 Would like to suggest that your correspondent have a general glance over the whole articles of Chin gage law and that of other states his own state and by studying them comparatively, he may' feel what has said is positively groundless.

DANIEL, P, Ciro, Shanghai, Dee, 10,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account