The Archive · 1936

An Express Trust

Plaintiff contends it is entitled to priority over general creditors because the arrangement under which the sales were made precluded the passing of complete title to the pro Ceeds to the bank. Plaintiff maintain the written agreement created an express trust under which belli the Dhysieal travelers cheques and the proceeds from their sales were held by the penk as trustee, and that the Tiguidator standing in the shoes of the insolvent bank is charged with the responsibility of performing the obligation of this trust by paying over the proceeds in full to the plainti 20m the funds coming into his hands. There can be no question that the tank held the physical travellers cheques in trust but defendant argues that the written trust agreement did not impose a trust on the proceeds of the cheques, Plaintiff, among other authorities, cites two' cases quite similar to' this one in which it was decided the proceeds of travellers cheques were held in trust and therefore became preferred claims against an insolvent bank, One case American Express Company against the Commercial Savings Bank Trust'Company, decided by the Court 9 Appeals, Lucas County, Ohio, on June 10, 1935, but not reported. The other Is American Express Company Hansen, Supervisor of Banking (Wash.) 28 Pac, 2nd 788. In doth cases, however, the form of trust agreement employed by the American Express Company and the bank speel-cally mentioned that the proceeds the travellers cheques when sold should at all times remain the property of the American Express Com-Dany. In both. cases the written agreements definitely imposed a trust on the proceeds as' well as on the physical travellers cheques. In the Instant gase the plaintiff relies on the words which constitute the scant agreement between the parties, "Received In TRUST for the American Express Company, signed travellers cheques as follows:...for which we accept the responsibility of due issue and agree to account therefor." From the phrase, "agree to account therefor," plaintiff attempts to spell a trust on the proceeds. This phrase, in the pinion of the Court, implies nothing more than a promise to ascertain the amount due and to pay it,.and con-hip. rms only a debtor-creditor relation-

From the allegations of the complaint it appears that the course of conduct between the parties has been inconsistent with the idea of a trust fon the proceeds, or at least negatives an Intention to maintain the trust if tone was originally created. From the complaint it appears the bank did not keep the proceeds separate or remit them in the form received, but ce: mingled the proceeds with the other assets of the bank in its general fund and from time to time delivered its draft on New York to the plaintiff in payment of what-might be due. The plaintiffs unvaryingly took the drafts This conduct seems conclusive that the parties did not intend the (rust to exist after the sale of the travellers cheques regardless of the meaning of the written trust receipt, that plaintiff consented to regard itself as a creditor rather than a cestul que trust, and that any trust relationship which might have been created by the writ. ing gave way to that of debtor and creditor. As Vice-Chancellor Lewis said in the case of Re. Luppe, 108 W. J. £q. 149, 153 Atl, $42." construing the' provisions of the trust dead, 1 cannot but think that there is manifest wisdom in the old rule that the law will regard not only that which is expressed but also that which is done by the parties thomselves in furtherance of their agrecment." This view is sustained in the case of Smith v. American Express Company, 152 60. 171, where the facts were similar to the instant case but more favourable to the Express Com-any because the written trust receipt specifically recited a trust on the proceeds. In that ease the Court said:

seering sales, nter"an "Americas At ist the bank remitted da "Travel Year before the ror sever Dank' taited, remit lances were made semi-mouthy. Sheers same ate

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account