Jan, 28, Our contributor S. A. F. E., to-day, replying to a recent article of Mr. Rodney Gilbert, thinks that it jot encouraging for the future" that foreign ers should be "irate with the diplomatic body, which is trying' to conciliate the Chinese." If means to imply, or has any misgiving, that foreigners are angry' because the Diplomatic Body is trying to conciliate the Chinese, he is wrong. In any other sense, he himself supplies the cause lof what he deplores, when he says that a Communist government in China could "scarcely be worse than the present federation of military dictatorships limited only by their capacity for mutual destruc: tion." 'That is so apt a descrip-lion of the existing state government in China that it is rather a pity our contributor' did not consider its bearing on what the Diplomatic Body are trying or are supposed to be trying to do, and on the average foreigners' opinion thereof. Our contributor laments. that men' jate less disposed than formerly, to accept the guidance "of those in high places who understand the Chinese." Whether the men in high places understand the Chinese we de not know: but they certainly appear blind, it would almost seem wilfully so, to actual conditions as our contributer has so vividly described them. Hence the disrepute into which the Diplomatic Body has fallen.
It is because he is not blind to those conditions and refuses to pretend that things are other than they are, that Mr. Rodney Gilbert, whose understanding of China is founded on long ielence, wide travel and an excellent knowledge of the lange wage, has earned some unt m|Popalarity latterly with others besides S.A. F. E., including Chinese. We know they ti him bitter'and it would only be human nature if. they resented his saying things about their politicians which they themselves would say with great heartiness. However much we attack our own countrymen, we dislike hearing others do so. But might not those who quarrel with Mr. Gilbert's sharp sayings consider that they truly arise from the most genuine affection for China? Here is a great and wealthy country, full of the most charming people, whom the more one knows the more one fikes and admires; and they have-got into the toils of some demented kind of political system, which is hurting and wronging them abominably, We. ido not attempt to say who is to blame for this, nor dub any one class miscreants battening jon the rest, We have often expressed the conviction that the much-abused Tuchuns are very likely sincerely desirous of doing Jsomething for China's good. Almost any individual (no matter in what country), if taken by himself, is capable of high pirations: but he gets caught in the web of party intrigue and "there's an end don't." polities the vicious effect of the mob spirit is visible more most than anywhere. But there at any rate is the fact that China is in a state of political Jdisorder which is doing her infinite harm and which everyone seems helpless to cure; and no honest man can shut his eyes to it, nor; if he be a profession-jai writer, refrain from coni-menting on it.
As for British prestige, we would not presume to whether it is permanently lower than it used to be or what might be done for its rehabilitation, In spite of our contributor's kind suggestion that all the best men were killed off in the war and we must accordingly put up with what we can get from second-raters, we believe that Britons abroad are very much what they used to be, dull in some things, shrewd in others, neither more nor less fitted to make themselves popular than they ever were, on the whole conscientious, reasonably honourable in business and_with peculiar codes of justice, the inability to depart from which often militates against their own interest. Slow to change, they find it dificult to perceive p sible modifications, or what may ultimately prove to be such, of obvious facts. We realize the prevailing disorder in this Jcountry, but we may be inclined to underrate the forces working energetically, however blindly and erratically as yet, to put them right; and as these forces jate at any rate vocal and expressive, the Briton is donounced to all the world for his impatience and lack of sympathy. This has to be altered, land the only way of doings is by personal contact and individual effort,—Whether the reformers in China might be helped from without is an important point. Our contribu-for asks for a constructive sugjzestion and we can only fall back on the one often made in these columns: that the Powers should invite all the principal military and—political _and student leaders to a personal conference, to see whether, under the touch of personal! contact and frank discussion' their present differences, which iso much afflict China, might not} prove imaginary.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.