Counsel on cither side having summed up, the Judge gave the following explanation of the law as applying to this particular case, He said that, if two persons quarrelled and ' afterwards tough!
id one killed the other, the killing manslaughter because—to engage in a fight was not. a lawful act. It did not matter in a fight who happened to have struck the first blow: the one who struck the fatal blow would be guilty of manslaughter. The question of provocation was immaterial from a Jury's point of view. On conviction ty a jury, it was for the Judge to consider whether there had bee such provocation as to justify a lesser punishment. Self-defences meant that a man must be in such' jon that nothing romaine.
im but to protect. himself in order to save his life. In this ease there was nothing to show that th Prisoner ever was in auch danger.
After a short absence from Court, the jury returned a verde? of guilty.
The Judge said the prisoner did not start the quarrel and he wou not have fought at all if the deceased man had not provoked him. However, he did engage in a fight and it was an unfortunate blow that killed the deceased. was a judge's duty not only inflict punishment on the guilty bu! to impose sentences that would show other people that they must for commit similar offences, is ease, the prisoner must serve months' i whicl could be The fury wera exempted fom teri of ewe yous
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.