From this evidence he had to Gecide whether the defendant was guilty of negligence and, Whether the plaintiff was free from contributory negligence, If the €efendant was not guilty negligence and acted prudently then that was the end of the case, There was no direct evidence to show that! the defendant was guilty of negligence except the rapidity with the car was being driver. But he considered that even if the hho did not consider that thi negligence per se as their was no other trafic and, according to the evidence, the car was travelling in the middle of the road. He was irelined to believe that the car as being driven at that pace but he had seen ears being driven ey day in the busiest streets of the Cty at a speed almost as fast, Tt seemed to him if these were' the erly facts on which negligence wat aimed there was very little to substantiate it, Looking at it as icasonable men they could not help believing that something happened to startle the horse at the time it reached the Haig Riding Schoo! an that it became ungovernable. It not_an unusual thing for a horse to bolt into a gate through which it was accustomed to entorand the mere fact that the rider not again notice the ear until ident served to show that 1 happened to divert his the horse's head. The plaintif€ had said that the accident happened 90 ft. away from the rate Fut he was picked up from the ground directly opposite the gate.
had come to the conclusion that was just one of those cases in the rider of a fractious horse Fad it under contro! until an une expected moment and in this case that was the time when the rate of the school was reached. Tt was more tran probable that the rider pulled the horse's head to one side when nearing the gate and either the horse or the rider did not notice nearness of the car and the animal swerving was struck by it, He felt quite satisfied that there was no negligence on the part of tne driver of the car and would consequently find for the defendant.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.