The Archive · 1926

COMMITTEE"

Feb.

Mucit interest has been arcused by the news of the: for-motion of a China Committee to} watch events in the Far East] and try to arouse the Government accordingly. Some of the principal commercial and financial houses in China are repre-vented, besides the Federation of British Industries, the Lon~ don Chamber of Commerce and the Chamber of Shipping. Some! curiosity is felt as to why Baron Southborough was chosen as chairman,—His record shows no particular knowledge of China, beyond what he may have picked up, via Hongkong, between 1907 and 1911, when he: was Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies. He was formerly. Mr, Francis Hopwood, a solicitor, who very early became assistant law clerk to the Board of Trade and was then private secretary to its President, He has served on several important Royal Commissions and knows a good deal of the Empire by personal visits: altogether a business expert, on official lines, if not a China one and, it is to be hoped, endowed with leather lungs. To is offer of the services of the new Committee, we are told that Sir Austen Chamberlain replied welcoming its formation, promising gladly to avail himself of its offer of ce-operation and inviting practical constructive schemes which "the wide experience embodied in the committee may from time to time suggest for the relief of the present serious situation." All of which, like notices convening the meeting, reports and accounts and "the above-named gentlemen playing upon the aforesaid musical instruments" may be "taken as read." The British community of China and) Hongkong are weary of fair promises and high-sounding speeches from the Secretary of State for Foreign' Affairs and have ceased to attach any reality' of meaning to them. If the new! China Committee is going to be content to cooperate with the Foreign Office, it may as well have never been formed.—Its] only chance of doing something "fective is to endeavour to work up feeling in the country and especially to form a vigorous China party in Parliament.

It can hardly be disputed that British policy in China needs radical overhauling. In so far as it seeks to enter into sympathetic rela ese people, it is wholeheartedly of contradiction' that in the present execution of this policy the i the Chinese people are'. not studied; that to negotiate the unrepresentative and nerve-jess Government in Peking is beneath the dignity of the! Powers; and that endeavours to come to any terms with that Government by which China may! be benefited will prove not only tile but dangerous to. the whole country.

The Customs Conference has been itting in Peking since the middle of October and the Extraterritoriality Conference—which ought to be moving about China, not sitting still, but is unable to do} so—since December.

What has either achieved? What meetings have been held for weeks past?' What does either expect to say that it is an insult to the Powers that the Peking Government should keep these men dawdling about and a humiliation to the Powers that} they should suffer it. In the present position at Canton we have an unanswerable test of what the Peking Government is. Either it can stop the boycott; and if so, why does it not? Or it cannot stop it, and then what} sort of a mi is Peking in its own house and where is the use of treating with it for the performance of mutual promises in which it obviously cannot} guarantee to do its part?

In a further direction British policy needs revision. We touch! on this aspect of the question' reluctantly and with the most] earnest hope that we shall not} be misunderstood. But it can-rot be thought that United States guidance in the Far East! is a safe or consistent one to follow and there is too much reason to fear that the British Foreign Office is still following, it far too unquestioningly. We believe sincerely in Anglo-American cooperation; on that, as the late Dr. Page consistently} preached, depend the future destinies of the world. But it] must be cooperation, not subservience to a leadership which] Washington's experience of foreign policy is still relatively too immature to entitle her to take, not to forget the considerable) section of her Congressmen who} intensely dislike her having foreign policy at all. In this) connexion we are sure we are at one with our American busi ness friends in China. They} chafe under the complacency of their Government, as we do under ours, and, like us, have made repeated representations to it, based on accurate perception facts, with apparently as little success. There is no collision between the ideals pursued by Great Britain and America in, the Far East, but, as the men lof both nations on the spot) clearly see, the manner of mak-} ing them realities is a very different question. We have only to recollect the varieties of]! American policy in China in the) past fifteen or twenty years—Mr. Knox's attempt to neutralize Manchurian railways, which) merely threw Russia and Japan into each other's arms; President Taft's forward policy and insistance on American parti-/ cipation in China railway loans; against her chief representatives chang is directly concerned.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account