The question put by Mr. H 'T, Muggeridge in the House of Commons on the subject of the maintenance of British troops China was duly and properly. answered by the Secretary of State for War, No good pur-ose would be served by attaching supreme importance to it from one point of view. There 4s a certain school of thought in the Labour Party peculiarly susceptible to suggestions"which compare the British resident: overseas unfavourably with his compatriot at Home and which minister subtly to the plausible arguments of the anti-Imperial-sot the "North-
News" have reason to know that on this matter the present Government is as orthodox as any of its predecessors. Just six months ago a special message to this journal from very well-infamed military correspondent in London, dealing with the annual estimates, contained the following very signi-leant remarks:
"Labour poli ans have been somewhat staggered by the information given in committee on the immense volume of trade which they have to protect, a "commerce vital to the United Kingdom conducted from what is in effect a British coast me in the China sea."
Mr, Shaw is the last person to Agnore the implications of this position and he certainly does not share the curious views of 1 Mr. A. W. Haycock who, Cans n-born commercial traveller a Member for Salford West, to be lacking in a robust commercial faith. Mr, Haycock's supplementary question, which was promptly blocked by the Chair, throw a definite light 0: the intention of his Romfor colleague's question. Although, in the main question, there wa 4 gen reference to "British jects. in China" and the "British Army in China," th cockers after truth were reality not concerned with the arrangement which has for ome twenty years kept British troops in Tientsin or with the garrisoning of Hongkong. Th Minister was being heckled i effect on the question of Shang: hai.
Without incurring the charge of over-sensitiveness Shanghai may quite reasonably sce here the traces of that vigorous propaganda which is constantly seeking to establish in the eyes of the British people the reputation of Shanghai for selfish turpitude, moral obliquity and unpatriotic hedonism, and te confine the gravamen of. the charge to the body of British residents here. It would be enough, of course, to point out, very meekly, to. Messrs, Mug. ge ridge and Haycock that Shanghai is not British-owned, that it is an international settlement, that if it were taxed for the upkeep of British troops posted here the British Army would be in the ignominious position of being in receipt of 'a substantial subsidy from foreign nations. Mr, Shaw did not forget to remind his friend that the Shanghai Municipal well relieved the Army of ent and taxation which otherwise accrue from "the occupation of the land and buildings used by the Defence Force troops, To that extent the Force is supported by funds which are in part of foreign origin, As presumably the units in question would have to be maintained in some part of the globe, the chances are that, un-Jess the trooping charges unduly swell the account, the British taxpayer does not come so very badly out of the gain. There is too the pertinent inquiry whether the Settlement, when asked, has refused to pay for the upkeep for the Defence Force. It is most unfortunate that the spirit which seems to animate these enquirers should be manifested at this moment.
The British community in Shanghai is no aggregation of drones, It covers about 8,000 salaried workers whose taxes, if based on those paid in England now, would amount relatively to little. The rest of the community may be better off but they are not of the leisured class; they are essentially workers who, when they have accumulated—competences, will probably retire to England—to be taxed by the Inland Revenue Department on the unearned in: crement basis. Yet, for the reater portion of their lives, they have been deprived of the amenities which provide solid compensation to the home-staying taxpayer. This British community in Shanghai—like its American, Japanese and other fellow-citizens—constitutes the spearhead of British trade in the Far East. It claims no special perfections. It admits human weaknesses inherent in the manner of its labours. Iv can claim however, with others in like case, that it has pioneer ed when risk, courage and action were required. It has experienced all the vicissitudes of conditions in a country where, from time immemorial, the merchant has had to rely on his personal tenacity and patience to overcome the asperities of climate, cultural prejudices and the like. Indeed the British in China might well ask the Government of their own country whether, taking the example of other Governments, all has been done that could be done to equip these pioneers and ambassadors with the knowledge and infor-motion to be obtained mi readily from official enterprise than from private sources. Have the Government in fact given the consular services and, in particular, the commercial branches of those services the unstinted support appro} to a nation whose trade i paramount—importance?
British in Shanghai have been experiencing the—unpleasant shock of a gravely depressed currency, like the rest of their fellow-citizens. The shock hi in two years, involved the hal ing of private and public capital. This is then a most unfortunate occasion to choose for raising doubts of the worth of the community which the Shanghai Defence Force is partly helping to defend. In China at the moment is a Mission charged with the duty of learning and porting on trade conditions for the good of British enterprise at Home. That Mission must depend on the community assai:- od by Mr. Muggeridge and his Mugwump friends for advice, assistance and eventual support of projects ultimately planned It is to be hoped that Sir Ernest Thompson and his colleagues, face to face as they are with the realities of Shanghai and China; will carry with them sufficient materia: to refute flimsy arguments which, unconscious though their users may be of the fact, are being exploited for the sinister purpose of undermining the good name of this Settlement. It is certain that the cause which the Government desire to further in sending the Mission here will be scurvily
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.