I have just finished reading the verbatim report of the trial of Pyatakov, Radek and the rest of tie sevenieon men recently charged with high treason, ete., before the Military Collegium of the Supreme Court of the USSR. That almost 600 pages of an English. transla~ tion of the shorthand notes could have been printed, bound and sent to Shanghai in the space between the conclusion of the trial January 30 and the beginning of last week speaks volumes for' the eMciency of those responsible for the production of this very interest~ Ing document. It is very well produced and shows every evidence of careful editing.
But the dificult task of perusing long a report has left me just as cynical with regard to the whole affair as T was in reading the brief daily recounts carried by the news agencies during the trial itself. Let there be no mistake about it, if the accused were indeed guilty of the crimes alleged against them, if the method of investigation and trial were not open to so much suspicion, there would not be the slightest doubt that the men richly deserved the sentences meted out to them, the law of Soviet Russia being what Its. But then they all deserved it, and one of the preliminary doubts that arises is why such an arch traitor as Radek escaped with his life, while Pyatakov, who is certain ly ho worse an offender, and the twelve others were made'to forfeit their lives.
That this statement is correct fs proved by the remarks of the Prosecutor, Vyshinsky who in one of his tirades says:—
Such workers for merit for Trotskylsm, 1 would call them, as Pyatakov, "Radek, Drobnis, Serebiyakoy "and Boguslavsky, cam outaged themselves, resorted blackmail, cheated their own people and others. Only In a mildew such 'a5 that created by the Pyatakovs ded people who used their highly responsible posts in the Soviet state system for the purpose of perpetrating their shameful, sordid and bloody crimes sonly th such a miller could a Trotskyite actif, Ki Arnolds, Strolovs and Hrasches, Radek, Arnold, Sokolnikov and Strollov escape death, but Pyatakov and the others die under the fire of machine gun. There seems to be 44 capriciousness about the ultimate execution of the law which throws about the whole proceedings that cloud of suspicion which it is so dimeult to remove.
These seventeen men after weeks of preliminary investigation during which they are alleged to have broken down and confessed their crimes so hideous in the eyes of the prosecution, eventually are brought to trial, From this point we must forget the Anglo-Saxon ideas of the Vindleatlon of justice and consider: the methods of the Moscow Court.
It Is all very different. A lengthy indictment, setting forth much of what has been given in testimony the preliminary Investigation and winding up with a formal charge is read over to the accused. They are ced if they plead guilty, and unanimously they reply that they do.
'A person accused of murder in England, and admitting his guilt, has been sentenced to death in a few minutes. But from January 23 to January 30, seven long days, the Court holds an investigation into the charges which have been admitted. "For a whole week the defendants under Interrogation glibly admit their guilt. They rarely, if ever deny anything alleged against them by the Prosecutor. Indeed they compete with themselves in blackening their own reputations in the eyes of their countrymen, Radek so widely extends his plea of guilty that he makes himself admit criminal acts of which he did not know. The necessary amount: of corroboration by witnesses {s introduced. And then the Prosecutor Vyshinsky gets in some deadly work.
"This trial," says he, shortly after opening his final speech, "has vealed and proved the stupla obstinacy, the reptile cold-bloodedness, the' cool calculation of professional criminals with which the 'Trotskyite bandits nave been waging _thelr "struggle against "the USSR. They stuck at nothing—neither wrecking, nor diversions, nor espionage, nor terrorism nor' treason to their country.
'When several months ago, in this very hall, in this very dock, the members of these-called Trotskylte-Zinovievite terrorist centre were' sitting: when the Supreme Court, represented by the Military Col-logium, was trying those criminals, all of us listened to the story of their crimes that unfolded itself Uke a nightmare scene before us, with horror and revulsion.
Every honest man in our country, every honest man in every country' say: in the world could not then but!
This is a abyss of degradation!
This is the limit, the last boundary of moral and poliileal decay!
This 1s the diabolical infinitude of crime!
Every honest son of our country thought to himself: such hideous crimes cannot be repeated. There cannot be in our country any more people who have fallen so low and who have so despicably betrayed us.
But now we are again overcome with sentiments that we felt not Tong ago. Once again across our anxious and wrathful vision pass frightful scenes of monstrous crime, of monstrous treachery, and monstrous treason, That's good hot stuff calculated to sway any Jury. But there is none. He Is addressing a Court composed of three jurists not likely to be swayed by his eloquence if they had to make any decision as to the accused's guilt, a task of which the defendants themselves had kindly relieved them, Vyshinsky then proceeds to deal with the accused ad seriatim:
This investigation has proved that Radek, Pyatakoy and their accomplices started and carried on hegollations with foreign aggressors, with their representatives, in antilpation of military ald from them, and promising them various econo: mic and. political advantages, cluding the surrender of paris of the Soviet territory. The traiters were ready for everything, even for selling their native land. They conspired to commit the blackest treason: they sank lower than the worst Dentkinltes or Kolchakites. 'The worst Denikinites and Kolchakites were superior to these traitors. 'The worst Denikinites, Kolehakites and Milyukovites did' not sink Tow og these Trotskylte Judases who sold their native land for 30 pieces Of silver, and these counterfeit who tried to place, our country bondage to foreign capital. These: are facts," The investigation has established them and no one can] controvert them, might have added that the defendants had admitted them, but perhaps that was not necessary. His hearers in Court and out of it! would remember that. M. Vyshinsky denies that there are any extent: ing circumstances to be advanced fon behalf of the accused, and referring to those killed and wounded in the acts of terrorism alleged against the accused, concludes his} speech thi am not the only accuser! Comrade Judges 1 feel that by my' side stand the victims of the crimes son crutches, and perhaps Tegless, Itke Comrade Nagovitsina, the, siwiicrsirl at Chusovacaya Slatlon, who appealed tome through the "Pravda" to-day, and who, at 20 years of age, lost both her legs averting a train disaster organized by these people! T do not stand here alone! "1 feel that by my side here stand the murdered and maimed victims of these fright. ful crimes, demanding of me. as Stale Prosecutor that I press. the charge on all points T do not stand here alone! The victims may be in their graves, but I feel they are standing here beside me, pointing at. the. dock, at you, accused, with their mutilated arms which have mouldered in the graves to which you have sent Tam not the only accuser! T am Joined in my accusation by the whole of our people. I accuse these heinous criminals who deserve only. one punishment—shooting by death.
'Most of the defendants waive the' right to speak in their own defence. Of what avail? What defence can they possibly put up? Counsel for some of them address the Court, but M. Vyshinsky does not even deign to reply to their arguments. He knows that the trial is progress-Ing toward its inevitable end.
'Then come the last pleas of the accused, Starting with Pyatakov they beat their breasts and shout fan ever increasing crescendo "mea culpa, mea maxima culpal'
Pyatakov:—I am too keenly conscious of my crime, and 1 do not venture to ask for clemency, T will not even make bold to) ask for mercy In a few hours you will pass sentence. "And here I stand before you in filth, crushed by my' own crimes, bereft of everything by my own fault, a man, who has lost his party, who has.
friends, who has' lost his family, who has lost his. very, self, Radek:—We cannot, nor can I ask for clemency, we have no right to it. And T will say—there is no pride here; what pride can there be?—that we do not neod, clemency.
Sokolnikov:—I do not doubt the fairness, the absolute Imparllality of the Supreme Court of the Union, T think that everything of an extenuating. character, everything that speaks of clemency that may be found in my own case or in the cate of others will be weighed by the Court, I therefore will not mention anything thet. seems to me speaks in favour of clemency........
But as regards the general responsibility of the accused and not their individual responsibility I repeat that I think that the Trotskyite vrganiza-Hon, that Trotskylsm self Is dead, has come to be hated by. the masses, has been buried and cannot rise again, "I think that this circumstance perhaps may bbe regarded os a reason. for clemency and through the Court to our whole people for whose forgiveness I publicly plead, And so through the long lst of accused. Some appeal for mercy that they may try and make some amends for the crimes they have committed, others ask it it is possible to be saved from a shameful death. Shestov has only one desire, to stand with the same calmness fon the place of my execution and with my blood wash away the stain of a traditor to my country.'
The sorry tale of recantation pro-' ceeds until 7.15 pin. on January 29, when the Court adjourns.
At 3 am. the next day the Court! reassembles. Most think that there will be only one judgment—death for all the accused. The finding is read. Thirteen of them are to die. Radek, Sokolnikow, Arnold and Stroilov escape with terms of imprisonment. A very few hours later thirteen men fall before the rattle of a machine gun, four go to prison to expunge their crimes by years of suffering.
One is glad that some of them did not die. But, nevertheless it dimMcult to see from the record why any of them escaped. Why did they? Why did all the accused confess s0 readily? Why did they pile more and more guilt upon themselves? Why was the trial ever held at all? Not all who are arrested and executed pass on their way to death through the Courts, These questions may never be answered, though there will always, remain the uncomfortable suspicion that all was not so clean and above board a8 this lengthy verbatim report would have the reader believe.
all so amazingly glib, Indeed the whole thing reminds one of the story of the teacher in Russia who asked his class:—"Now tell Eugene Onyegin?"—(Pushkin's famous work).
The class sat dumb. Turning to! the smartest boy in the class he repeated the question, The boy stood shamefaced and When what was done in the way of murdering and maiming people Indignant at the youth's lack of! general knowledge the teacher wrote to his parents, and in reply in Russia a bare twenty years ago received a letter to the effect that is recalled, M. Vyshinsky seems to the lad was a good boy, and, if he
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.