The Archive · 1926

House of Commons Debate

To-day was opposition day in the House of. Commons in connexion with the Budget. Mr. Philip Snowden, former Labour Chancellor of the' Exchequer, took full advantage of the occasion, accusing Mr. Churchill of increasing national expendi-"ture by £30,000,000 in 18 months} and of making an outrageous settle. ment. with Italy simply in order to get £4,000,000 including in the present Budget, The Government, said Mr. Snowden, was undoubtedly in the grip of the banks and financial houses, whi Mr. Churchill's statement regarding] the silk duties was sheer humbug.

The ex-Chancellor criticized the betting tax most scathingly, which, he said, would outrage the most sacred feelings of a vast number of people and would lead to collusion between backers and bookmakers.

He recalled that, he described last} year's Budget as the rich _man's Budget: this year it was a Budget of the profligate and the bankrupt (Load Labour cheers.)

Sir John Simon's criticism was milder. He thought the betting tax would be regarded as an imprimatur on a form of excitement which would cause havoc in homes when indulged in excessively. Moreover, the tax would encourage illegal forms of betting.

'Sir John Simon warmly repudiated] the Chancellor's competence with! regard to a ten years' guarantee of Imperial Preference.

Mr ton Churchill's Reply Apr. 28.

In the House of Commons to-day, unperturbed by the vehemence of the criticism oP his budget, Ar. Winston Churchill, replying to the budget debate, serenely voiced his inability to remember an} incurring such a weak, discursive and contradictory oppos tion. He claimed that it was more nearly a virtually agreed budget than any during the past quarter of a century, This remark was greeted with laughter and cheers.

Mr. Churchill went.on to say that he welcomed the discussion of all i connexion with the betting tax: he would make the tax work as simply as possible. As regards the stabilization of imperial preferences, the Chancellor admitted that another parliament would be able to repudiate the guarantee but the fact that a positive step was taken would act as a practical de-torrent, whereas he hoped that with the passage of time these matters Imperial Consolidation would more and more cease to be the pawns of party controversy Reuter.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account