Industry's Great Handicap: British Dyestuffs: Dr. Levinstein Criticizes Lord Ashfield an address on. "The. dyostuits industry and the State," given the Dyers' Hall, London, Dr. He1 bert Levinstein traced the development of the industry during the! past 60 years; showed. the great' war-time importance to Germany of, factories and plants which in peacetime had produced dyestuffs; and conc]uded with a strong criticism of Lord Ashfield's connexion with the dyestuffs industry and an attack upon, the "cult of the preferably titled amateur in business."
Dr. Levinstein showed how the presence of the great dyestuffs factories in Germany determined, in sense, the whole course of the later "stages of the war. These factories, with trifling adaptations, produced, ind afterwards for the gas offensive, Even in a matter parently 10 trial as the dyeing of service uniforms Dr. Levinstein showed the great importance to the: State of the dyestuffs industry.
We wore able, he said, in the first few days of the war to inform the military clothing officials that a supply of dyes equal in fastness to the German dyes would be made available promptly: if their use w authorized. T think I may say day that without the provisions th Kitchener's armies would not have Joined their French comrades for many months later than was the ease if Coomassie navy blue, with or without the conjunctive use of] Indigo, became the staple colouring matter for the navy.
"Later on great orders were executed in this country for Russian, Belgian, and French uniforms, the dyes for which were made in Great Britain and supplied without any delay. Yet before the war not a pound of dye for a British uniform was supplied or could have been supplied by British makers. Tt was, German and had to be German."
Turning to the part played by the German dyestuffs industry during the war, Dr. Levinstein said that when the Germans launched their offensive in August, 1914, they had accumulated a store of explosives: '80 vast, as it appeared to the minds of the German General Staff at the date, to make it seem certain that they' could blast their way through the armies of any civilized nation; that they could break their moral, by a tornado of destruction, and that they could destroy any French or Belgian strong points. When the German armies reached the Marne their reserves of ammunition hnd been expended. The courage and endurance of the opposing troops had falsified the Germai predictions—Paris threatened was yet intact—armies thrown back were yet in line.
"It is a common error to suppose' that the German aniline dye indus-tay had contributed to the piling up of these stores of high explosives. To do 0 is to misunderstand the German military mind and greatly to! underrate the subsequent work of the German LG, (the largest dyestuffs organization in the world). Before the Marne the German mili tary organizations demanded nothing of the German dyestuffs i They mobilized all their chemists of military age. The pre-'Marne explosives came from the explosive factories and regular arsenals of Germany.
"What a change took place after the Marne!
The certainty of quick anished, along with the I.G. was wanted, and by providing first the explosive, and then tthe toxic chemicals, it' saved the German cause for the time and pro-Jonged the war for four more years."
This situation in which an exist ing peace-time organization could respond at the shortest notice to war-time calls, Dr. Levinstein_contrasted with the condition of affairs in England, where very large sums of money were spent in erecting now perfectly useless sulphuric acid, nitric acid, and nitrating. plants. 'There was naturally a long interval before there was delivery from these tastenes, which had to be: design-fu, erected, staffed, and commission-while in Germany" there was virtuaily"no' time: lost" The -Germans had an enorfious ddvantdga' in these aniline dye factories, which, in their owa standardized "plant, fed by their own acid plants, could produce and did produce at short notice high explosives on a scale far greater than those of the regula arsenals of other countries."
Dr. Levinstein then spoke of the manner in which the gas offensive, and even the very gases used, were! conditioned by the dye industry.
"On April 25, 1915, the first gas attack was launched. "It was merely liquid chlorine. Why chlorine? Because the 1.G. alone made 50 to 1650 tons of liquid chlorine daily. The production of this product in England at that time was about five tons per week. It was a surprise weapon to which obviously there could be -no quick counter. Never were the Allies nearer to losing the war than during that week.. Never till the end was there so wide a gap on the western front as after the first German gas attack in April, 1915. The whole the substances used for the toxic gases without exception were made in the German IG., and no other factories, I believe, made any single one of these substances, unless it be that some quantity of phosgene was produced at Von Hayden's.
"When did deliveries commence? When they were wanted. Phosgene was a pre-war product. Lachrymotors were made almost without altering the plant as early as March, 1915. We know the great delay there was in other countries before the production of any substance selected for use in the field."
In wartime potential arsenals' were infinitely more valuable than real arsenals. No Locarno Pact nor Washington Conference could limit the construction of such plants so long as in peace-time they found 4 legitimate outlet for their commodities. They brought in revenue, they did not figure in the military' estimates, but the citizens of every European nation, including our own, could sleep more comfortably they had the knowledge that behind the visible military strength there was this latent force to counter the possible activities of others.
Most of the victories gained in international affairs were diplomatic victories, gained not superior address on the part of one Foreign Office over another, but because the words were silently backed by the possession—as a last resort—of the means to enforce the interests of its nationals.
Describing the rapid advance of the British dyestuffs industry during the war and the way in which much of the ground gained had since been lost under Government control, Dr. Levinstein next turned his attention to Lord Ashfield.
"Not only did he at the Board of Trade waste two valuable years in carrying out what he had from the first declared to be his policy, but when he did bring it about he brought it about with a pledge—given both privately and publicly—which he did not fullfl. The pledge was that the Government of which he was a member would prohibit the import of foreign dyestuffs, into Groat Britain, save under licence, for ten years. As President of the Board of Trade he endeavoured to carry out this unde ug, in order to avoid the legisation which would otherwise have been necessary, by means of that convenient war-time device for avoiding Parliamentary control—an Order in Council.
"This order was declared to be an illegal order, by a decision of Mr. Justice Sankey in 1919. Against this decision the Board of Trade—no longer guided by Lord Ashfield—did not venture to appeal. In consequence of this blunder, at a most critical period just before the great slump in trade, German dyestuffs poured into this country in great quantities."
Soon after leaving the Board of Trade, Lord Ashfield took up the Government directorship; when this directorship was about to expire he became an ordinary director, and this was only a stepping-stone to the chairmanship.
"Had Lord Ashfield any technical qualifications for his'directorship?" the speaker asked.
"Alas, the truth is that Lord Ash-_ field knew little science and next to nothing about the dye-making industry. This cult of the preferably titled amateur in business unknown except in England. There is no such thing in America as a professional director. Those who run the big concerns are those who know every detail of the business and who have grown up with it.
'f'n saying these things I must: not bethought simply to be indulge ing in personalities. I am thinking of principle of general application
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.