The Archive · 1937

Qualified Architects Range of Choice

the Editor of the "Nonmn-Cuixa Daicy News"

Suj—I am interested in reading the letter from the Fellow of the Royal Institute of British Architects in your columns to-day. I agree with him when he says that many contractors, even real estate men, have posed often as "Architects" But ig wrong in saying that only those holding qualifications and degrees from the Royal Institute of British Architects, American Institute 'Architects' and Les Beaux Arts (apparently a mistake for Ecole des Beaux Aris in Paris) should be considered as architects, There are also those who hold the Diplome par Gouvernment Francais and degrees from American universities, Tt must, also be remembered that the American Institute of Architects. elects architects to membership but never wives "degrees, And, unlike—the RIPA, only American citizens are eligible for membership in the A.LA.

There are in Shanghai alone Chinese architects who are returned he] students from America, Englana, Germany and France, with some 30 of them holding American universi-degrees in architecture, There are also those that belong to the RILB.A. and hold the Diplome par lo Gouvernment Francais." The American returned architects come from Yale, Pennsylvania, Columbia, Michigan, Missouri, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Carnegie Tech and the Beaux "Arla School. in New York. They are. fully qualified architects, although not members of the ALA: There is no doctorate degree for Architecture given in any of the American universities, but architects high standing, be they foreign oF American, are elected into honorary Societies "ike Sigma X and" Tau Sigma Delta, to. which several Chinese architects. belong. Taking Into Account of these some 30 Chinese in the profession, its erroneous to say that out of" nearly. 100 listed architects, the result (Of picking out {ally qualified ones) is infinitesimal."

architects should free ourselves {trom the prejudice. that. those who not hold degrees in. architecture fire not and cannot be as good as we. itis only necessary to mention {wo the foremost architects in America, Charles" Kiauder and the ate Bertram Goodhue, who never went any" school of architecture. "The Erestest world exponent of modern Srehitecture, Frank Lloyd. Wright another instance. 'These men haw shown' such" an exceedingly standard of artistry and vision that, their work has become an inspiration to their fellow professionals. Looking at their work, We architects should fee! ashamed of our hollow degrees and high-sounding. affiliations. Come to think of i, weren't all the architects during the Renaissance no micro than mere craftsmen, although seme were painters?

B Cum Cuts, Master in Architecture University of Pennsylvania, Shanghei, Nov. 12,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account