Mar. 1.
The fact that, as a seton to the retirement of Mr. N. Leslie, Messrs. F. J. Raven and C.H.'Arnhold are standing as newcomers aspiring to seats on the Shanghai Municipal Council makes it inevitable that there will be a contested election next' week. On general grounds this is all to: the good; unopposed nominations tend to discourage that active interest which it is desirable that the electorate should take im the affairs of the Settlement. Mr. Raven has—from one point of view—already: endured judgment by a certain section of the ratepayers. In other words he has been nominated—with Mr. Carney a: candidate for _re-election—as. possessing the confidence of the majority of American voters, whose views have been ascertained by means of a pre minery canvassing of the chief American organizations here. 'This step was taken to prevent the recurrence of last year's results whereby an American' seat was lost, although the British candidates took special pains to ensure the continuance, of the recognized but unwritten practice of regarding two seats as reserved to the American community. My. Raven's prominence as a business man in Shanghai and the support which he has obtained from his own compatriots make him a suitable candidate, Not less suitable, from the British point of view, is Mr. C. H. Armhold who well seized of the problems of the Settlement, has long ac~ quaintance the needs of the! community and enjoys a reputation for competence and independence of view. No apology'
made for thus singling out the two newcomers for appreciation. It is due to them and to the ratepayers, especially in the: light of the importance of the coming year in Shanghaf's history and on account of the strong feeling that new blood in the Council would be desirable. The mere fact that the infusion, of good quality, will not be overwhelming in quantity should disarm even the most ardent apologists of the present regime.
Taking it for granted that the Japanese community cane!
ured of filling the two seats traditionally allotted to them, the assumption that the Americans will regain the seat which they lost last year, must rest in some measure on the'belief that the contest in point of fact will be limited to the election British members. In other} words: of the six British candidates it is expected that) tone will be unsuccessful, This} expectation might not be fulfilled if the ratepayer-voter disregards the unwritten practice] to which reference has been made. The British candidates this year are understood to be: disinclined to follow. precedent and make a public appeal for the voters first to vote for the Americans and Japanese so a8 to.secure the reservation of four seats equally divided - among! those two communities and then to vote by preference for the British candidates. This change in procedure is probably due to Maxwell's scheme. Thanks to the doubled export duty—ten per: cent. instead of five per cent. a conviction that the voters on such a matter do not look to the candidates for guidance. More-when the price is over sixpence—the employer of casual labour' would find quite a lot of his profit, cut off, and 0 would continue to restrict his tapping. Therewith a workable scheme is devised. Sir George Maxwell apparently vatarted out with the assumption that there was on "unrestrictover the new method whereby the American nominees have been put forward has made a difference in the situation. Tt has, however, strengthened' the contention that the Council should have two American members and, if, by any chance, the effect of a contested election would be to prevent that desirable area" rather than an unter able restoration of an old Practice, there would be much Tegret in many quarters. The difficulty is that the voter may' not realize the existence of this expose those defects in the columns of this journal; constructive suggestions have been made.
Council toward that report. will Become a matter of intense moment, It is most essential therefore that, the personnel of possibility until it is too late. The intrusion of personal factors might, too, conceivably upset calculations unless the plain} facts of the election were properly appreciated The adoption by the American community of the prima system has altered the situation in a practical way. It simplifies! the task of the British voter who. is sensible enough to realize that the Council would be the weaker if two seats are not filled by Americans. The candidatures of Messrs. Carney and Raven, from the British point of view, become those of the accredited representatives of the American community. The anomalies of the Constitution of the - Settlement, the necessity for the adoption of convention to make good certain definite lacunae, have, in the past, been met by the exercise of that common: sense and practical vision on which "Shanghai prides itself. Indeed the success achieved in working a Constitution which the Settlement in the "process of most amazing development, has" palpably outgrown, redounds highly to the credit of the electorate. Here then is opportunity for lof that admirable! quality. The British voter—unless the probable significance It is preposterous that Shanghai should be asked to accept the view that, unlike any other public body in the civilized world, the Council does not require to use modern methods of Maison with the Press and, through the Press, the pub: lic. One of the most curio ous performances in recent! weeks was the flagrant, correct tion of the minutes, after the publication in the Press of officially supplied summaries had brought to light an inconvenient statement, and the disingenuous use of the Gazette to father the mistake on the "North-China Daily' News." That incident alone should discourage unqualified praise of the Council's publicity methods. Whatever view be held of the decision to ban greyhound racing—the opinions of this journal are in no doubt—there Will "be general acceptance of the statement that the manner in has been com-Press from to time has left much to be desired. The existence of a properly organized publicity department would have prevent-Sled many of the unfortunate incidents which have exposed permanent officials—desiring to defend the Council to the best of their ability—to undeserved the Council shall be such that its views will carry the fullest authority and command respect virtue of the experience, known capacity and fair-minded ness of the, body from which they emanate. Exposition has already been given of the' in-plications of the nominations. 'The desirability of treating the four seats divided equally among the Japanese and Americans as free of electoral controversy need be merely' restated and left at that. There remains the lively problem of choosing from among six candidates five men to fill the other jgeats, To this problem it is hoped that electors will give most earnest attention. Their first task is to make gute that) between the hours of 10 aam and 3 p.m. either to-day "or to-morrow, they attend at the Administration Building, 209 Kiangse Road, obtain there their voting tickets and vote. They, should also. make a point of performing this duty at the earliest possible moment, order to avoid personal' inconvenience, to facilitate the work of the returning officer, and to. spare their fellow: Voters avoidable trouble. AS Voting will proceed through out the tiffin hours on, each day there is no excuse, except on ground of illness for the of the Japanese and America votes has been greatly mis-' judged—ean secure the right balance of nationalities on the Council, giving the Americane their two seats, if he or she' takes care, when voting next week, first to vote for the Japanese and Americans and then to distribute his or her remaining five votes among the six British candidates. The result will be that an old member of the Council may fail to secure re-election or that Mr.
H. Arnhold may not be successful in his candidature. For reasons already stated the latter result might be more regrettable than the former but} even more regrettable, even from the British point of view, would be the failure of the American community to win back the seat lost last year: In view of the consideration which the new Council will have to give to the report of Mr. Justice Feetham and the implications of its a8 yet unknown contents, it would be a tragedy if the Council did not carry that well-balanced international complexion which would defy criticism of its authority on future a policy. This danger can be! averted, so far as human' wisdom' can prescribe, by following the principles outlined above and urging on British voters the desirability of confining their polemical instincts in. the elec-jon to the choice of five out of the six British candidates after having given their first four votes. to the two American candidates, Messrs. J. W. Carney) and F. J." Raven and the two Japanese candidates, Messrs. K. Fukushima and 0. Okamoto respectively.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.