The Archive · 1926

Judge's Reference to Misleading Advertisements: Mr

Rakusen Justified in Practising as an Optician

"In H. M. Supreme Court, ansa degree of Doctor of Optics at Saturday, Judge Grain. gave his decision in the case in which Mr. F.R. Chichgar sued Mr. C. P. Rakusen, of the Oculists' Institute Go., for the return of money paid for eye-glasses and for damages goid to have been sustained through tthe defendant making the glasses on faulty prescription. Mr. M. B. Brown appeared for the plaintiff and Mr. K. E. Newman for the} he Judge held in favour of the; defendant, but disallowed costs, directing that each side should pay' his own. The judgment in full follows:—

This is a claim for damages, on _the grounds that the defendant jre-Bared eye-gla gligently and unskilfully," that the prescription "was not correct" and "not suitable fo the plaintiffs eye-sight" and that 'a result the plaintiff suffered pain und was kept from his work, and he mow claims damages for the pain he suffered, the five days he was Kept from work and a return of 120 paid to defendant for three! pairs of glasses, The defendant denies that he was guilty of negigonce, or unskilful conduct.

'The plaintiff? is a Parsee gentleman passing through Shanghai on business, His glasses are broken and, through advertisements, _ho eek t0, the Ocullsta' Institute Ca, get them mended. When he gets th is interviewed by the shop him, otary. The usual prousaistant, or, as his employer calls)

eedduve of the shopman is then adopt. '@d and the old goods are criticized and disparaged; and he is advised to discard his old goods and buy the mew goods of the shopman. For this purpose, he ly advised to have his eyes tested and is taken into! another room and is finally persuade to order three, or at least two, new pairs of glasses. According to Abe plaintiff's evidence, they wore never satisfactory, and he never aid they were.' According fendant, from the beginning, and all through, he said they were quite

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account