The Archive · 1937

Arguments: Three Justices May Retire Soon Frost Our Own Conararonoext

Washington, Apr. 23.

The Chief Justice of the United States, Mr. Charles Evang Hughes, spent the eve of his 75th birthday at~ {ending a function the like of which exists nowhere outside the United States,-a Gridiron Club dinner, The club consists of Leading Washington newspaper correspondents and its name 1s derived from the fact that exists for the purpose of "roasting" public officials in satirical skits.

On the evening in question there were present in addition to Mr. Roosevelt (he President of the United States always attends and makes 2 speech in which he can If he wishes anake a counter attack on those who have poked fun at his policies) such people as Secretary, Hull, the Vice President, the Speaker, Me. John TI. Lewis, Mr. Myron Taylor of United 'States' Steel and a host of Ambassadors and diplomats, The custom is to ask each guest fo rise if the skit to be performed any bearing upon him. Among all. those present the Chief Justice received most applause, more even than the "President. A glee, club sang "Happy Birthday to you" and the Chief Justice's smile. broadened, Though no one knew it at the time hho had knowledge of secret which every newspaper man present would have given: his. right hand to have een told—he knew how the Court was about to. give judgment in two days time on the Wagner Labour Act case:

So while fiticen Justices made up to resemble Caspar Milquetoast, the timid soul of the American comic strips, banged down their rubber Stamps approving "must" bills of the legislation and sang to the President. area of industrial activity within which the Federal Government could control labour relations. than had ven expected. Previous eases brought before the Court had drawn the Boundary. line within which the Federal Government could not oper-ale, Between these two boundary ings there was still a no man's land fu. whick It was uncertain whether the Federal writ or State writs should run.

Justice Roberts "Valle Face"

Other cases each decided on their merits will gradually bring together the two boundary Tines until it Is reasonably clear what industries are and are not subject to Federal Tabour legislation. Since" the ded sion was by a one vole majority and since Justice Roberts who usually st5 his vote with the "strict contructlonisis" bad "now joined the "iiberat constructionist," giving them 1 majority Administration leaders have begun {9 call the no man's land, "Robertsland" and complain. that Justice Roberls is the real dictator of, the country, "The Court did not reverse its pos!- tion on the Schechter chicken case which overthrow the NAIO. In fact pointed out once more that the killing of a chicken in New York, even it' the bird were hatched in New Jersey, could by no stretch of imagination be said to influence in-(orstale commerce, In fact the Sehechters Brothers business could—pass, and as a matier of fact had passed, out of existence without causing a ripple on the surface of the nation's economic life. But a big labour dispute was quite nother bird. would be just as lacking in com-nonsense to suppose that it had no Influence on national economic life and on the flow of interstate com-

Mr. Hughest Comment The Chief more than the wit warranted for he Hold tight a secret which might pre= vent the Supreme Court from being packed with six exiva Justices, Wagner Act Upheld The secret was made public properly by a serious faced Chier Justice Toss than 48 hours Jater. The Wagner Aet could be. applied. to such. big industeles una "manufacturing. con= corns as steel which were obviously national in scope, Congressional supporters of the President's court pack. Ing plan felt the ground was bein cut away from beneath their feet They ried softly For a face-soving compromise "but. the President was Sdamant. "One swallow did not make summer and one New Deal measure upheld didn't make a satstuetory Supreme Court, The Wagner "Act during the Yang Court debates tind. become a symbol of the kind of thing the. President Was "up axainal" "The assumption Was made that several of the eases brought before the Court Involving the Act, would go against, the Ad= ministration. See, the" President's supporters had s0i@, These terrible Sitedown strikes which we all deplore annet be tackled because they" take place in. industries which may not be considered by the Nine Old Men of the Court to be engaged In. Inter: Slate commerce, the only kind with which the Federal Government. may tinder the Constitution concern sel Hewas even suggested that the Court would deny the. constitutionality of Une. eentrar features of the Wanner Act and. the guarantees. it gave ganized labour against discrimination hoy employers. Arguments such a tore proved excellent ammunition when Administration spokesmen were tieing up support for the Prvsident's plan in industrial areas, AMI nine Justices of the Supreme court "agreed, however, onthe fundamental fact that Congress. wes perfectly within ite Constitutional Fights in legislating to protect labour Under the interstate commerce clause, 'The only difference of opinion was over the question of what industries were within the' Scope of the Act. AM nine agreed that a strike in an {nlerstate bus line would. obviously affect interstate commerce and. so feame under the get while five justices out of four agreed that four other industries which haa appealed against the Act as uneonsiltutlonal when apforms. "None of the "Justices sup ied to them. were covered by ts

ported the view that the Act was an Tnfeingement of the freedom of the individual to snake @ contract, The majority of the Court drew boundary line including a far wider Said the Chief Justice in giving the opinion of the majority In the most Important case before it (one dealing with a steel mill) "when industries organize themselves on a national scale, making their relation to inter~ slate' commerce the dominant factor fin their activities how can it be maintained that their "industrial Tabour relations constitute a forbidden field into which Congress may not enter when It is necessary. to protect interstate commerce from the Faralyzing consequences of indus war."

But when the Federal Government atlompls asin the NIA. act (0 regulate such minutes as the killing of chickens, "to find immediacy or [directness there was to find it almost everywhere, a result inconsistent with the maintenance of our Federal system." In other words the Chief Tustice was adopting as a rough rule fof thumb the view. that when the Stales could regulate industry they should, but when it was obvious that Fegulation was beyond their power then under the interstate commerce clause of the Constitution the Federal Government could.

Ho hold that Congress was within {ts Tegal rights when it recognized labour warfare og a direct cause of interruptions In interstate commerce, and having recognized that fact Con-ress could by appropriate legisla lon seek to remove such causes. Tu choosing. its methods Congress could Rot deprive employers of their right hire or fire workmen on. their merits, nor could any workman who had been fired for dereliction of duly take sheller behind his union card and insist that he should be re-employed, We could only appear to the Labour Reletions Board If he had been fred for joining a Union.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account