The Archive · 1937

SOVIET MYSTERIES

June 14, Marshal Tukhachevsky was to have been one of Russia's chief yeprosentatives at the Coronation of King George VI. Just before that event it was officially stated that he had caught a chill at the May Day celebrations in which ho was despite his then recent degradation 1o command of the Volta District, a prominent figure. The chill probably existed In fact but had a psychological rather than a physiological significance, for although the Marshal also appeared in apparently full favour at the parade of the Red Army on May 9, he was, in the light of after events, clearly on the brink of disaster, The sudden ness with which a hero of the Soviet regime may fall from grace and immediately acquire all the demerits of the blackest of traitors—on his own confession to boot—has been noted by all students of recent Russian affairs. The planation from the point of view of 8 British upholder of the Soviet system may be worth study. Mi Pat Sloan in "Soviet Democracy" nees to great pains to show that! democracy and dictatorship are not mutually exclusive terms. The argument briefly is that a democratic organization working f the benefit of the vast majority is bound to take stens to expel recalcitrant "minorities". The Soviet State, being surrounded by hostile find in practice that the device of sending ils opponents into exile is unsatisfactory because stich exiles are not acceptable {o rulers of foreign states and, moreover, their expulsion gives them the oppo tunity of carrying on their activity from outside. The exile, Mr. Sloan contends, is not merely one who has disagreed with the Soviet authority fon vital issues but one who, having made proposals and having been defeated, continues to obstruct all constructive business by repeatedly putting forward again find again the rejected point of View, and who thus becomes a thorn In the flesh of the whole of society.

Apparently Trotsky's activities broad made Moscow distrustful of the eMeacy of exile as a means of suppressing minority opposition, so the device of the State trial with its consequent extreme penalties was adopted.

Even on this basis it is dimeutt to imagine any great enthusiasm for democracy of the Soviet blend. Ibs, however, instructive to observe that the protection of the rights of minorities by which the original creators of the Soviet system were enabled to rise to power is definitely repudiated by their Frankenstein's monster, Marshal Tukhachevsky has been succeeded by Marshal Yegoroft who has been credited with holding different views from those of his immediate predecessor, Marshal Voroshiloff, until lately Marshal Tukhachevsky's colleague and chief, sits on the tribunal which in camera has sentenced the degraded officer to death for treason. In reviewing the names of the alleged traitors it is dificult to imagine what guarantee can be given that the process of protecting Russian democracy will not soon be dis~ covering more confessions of trea chary leading to the firing squad. 'The machinery seems to function with unerring accuracy. Despite the secrecy of the proceedings mass meetings prejudging the issues have been staged throughout Russia to show the solidarity of the workers' demand that the accused should be sentenced to death. Democracy, like liberty, has had many crimes committed in its name. This grim mass production of blood-lust yanks beside the worst of them, if the Soviet is to be regarded as the palladium cither of democracy or Mberty.

Perhaps it were better to leave for academic discussion the likeness of M, Stalin to a democrat and to contemplate the possibilities of this Tatest ruthless elimination of his alleged political opponents. The: romanticism which, paradoxically' enough. seems inseparable from the consolidation of the people's faith in Soviet Russia, is capable of receiving rude shocks' from {ls accredited exponents, The hero of romantic stories of the proletariat's triumph over Tsarism, whether he be Trotsky, Radek, Zinovieft or Tuk echevsicy, can be turned overnight, into a villain of the deepest dye. In the sense understood by a pur-ind capitalist world there is not the slightest proof of the reality of this transformation, The mere assertion that it exists—provided the repetition be frequent and loud enough—is all-sufficient. Specula. tions naturally arise regarding the possible effect of this ""blood-let~ ting" on the Soviet system. Will it be strengthened or weakened. would be dangerous to dogmatize.

M. Stalin is believed to have fol-.

Zowed up his destruction of the Oxnn''s power over the Red Army. with a new agreement designed to Lire-communize" that Army. Some have interpreted this as restoring

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account