The Archive · 1931

A Great Problem Bay 25

On the same day that he was receiving a civic welcome from Leeds, as reported at some England, the mass of the people are indifferent to and know nothing about principles of Government. They argue. therefore that the only practical policy is that of continuing—or rather reviving—the old system of personal rule and taking every material and physical precaution to preserve its integrity. The sentimentalists, obsessed by the belief that they alone have the gift of appreciating the feelings siderably below those available to. Nanking, the prospect of the engagement of the Government's troops in. yet another cam is not alluring. Gener Kai-shek appears to prudent measures, ing no stone unturned to secure a peaceful issue, he lets it be known that plans for military action are complete. The institution of the censorship in the cable offices is" represented as of the downtrodden, in spite of bel due to-apprehension of a length in another column this morning, Lord Irwin received a liar, if less elaborate but no more sincere tribute from the older City of York. There the Yormer Viceroy of India observ-en that the problem now being Yaced in India was the greatest with which the British Empire had ever been confronted:

"Te is nothing less than the question whether we can find the vight solution for the relationship between the coloured races of Asia and the white races of Europe, and whether we can fit India, into the great. self-governing Commenveaith of Nations of which we here happen to be the centre."

It is dificult to believe that the significance of this problem required to be stated in such definite terms, 'Yet there is little doubt that the need exists. During the last situation has, been consistently: before the British public in the columns of the more respon: newspapers to one Lord Irwin rightly paid a' warm tribute, Tt has been fitfully and exeltediy canvassed in. the so-called national Press in terms which at their worst must be said to have greatly aggravated the difficult of the problem and at their best have at least tacitly admitted the force of Lord Irwin's statement quoted above. In that statement Lord Irwin' shows that India is the immediate problem of the British Empire. It is also a world problem in the sense that the success with which the great adventure policy, now being pursued there, is attempted will largely govern the future relations between the East and the West. Sir John Simon gave eloquent, expression to this fact in one of his earliest speeches in India, It justifies the contentions of those who would urge that, in the intel gent study of the Indian prolem, lies a most important opportunity for applying solutions. to problems further afield. The mind which endeavours to reduce successive Indian crises to the level of controversy, over the wisdom of pledges given, over the merits of,"the firm hand and no nonsense" school, over the peculiar contumacy of oriental politicians. cannot contribute usefully to discussion of the problem, Suck am attitude, n its way, as dangerous and un: satisfying as that which persists in shutting the eyes to plain facts and in asserting the appearance of agreement when dissension is blatant and active.

Lord Irwin's speech at Leeds should give both those extreme schools of thought material for reflection, He bluntly told his audience that a political tornado had been raging in India.

Iti ies the nationalism to which the British Government _advisedly have long given express encouragemart, is an unreality appealing only to the political intelligentsia, It is equally futile for those supporters of his policy who derive their mental tenance from the flaccid sentimentalism of extreme La-our thought and whose support would be quivsly exchanged for ancorous hostility if the present government went out of office. fo pretend that the problem car:

solved by the: constant. application of s6porifie nostrils, regardless of thely effects. The curious point about these two divergent schools of thought in common a re-disdain for publ would not adm tions prevent any ation from being} attitude." The; id-time administrators with ex-! the fact that they' take their Instruction from those who perform the treading, would desire the establishment' of fantastic imitations of democratic government with which the actual conditions of the problem are grotesquely incompatible, It' regrettable that the peculiar composition of the British Goverament to-day inevitably gives such notions an importance which they do not merit. Mr. Wedgwood Benn finds the orities the Opposition sometimes difficult to manage on that ae count; otherwise it is not easy discern the reason for the asperity of his retort on the world-shattering issue of Mr, Gandhi's motoring habits.

The Government are pursuing' resolutely their policy of en~ deavouring to thrash out the Indian problem with the help of Indian thought. That is where Lord Irwin's insistence on the Paramount need of understanding between the "common mind of Great Britain and the com tron mind of India" is so timely. Much has been done in. the last few months to bring this understanding into existence. The. leading newspapers, such as the "Times" and "Yorkshire Post have been specially prominent in their sane guidance of opinion. The British Broadcasting Corporation is rendering yeoman service by instituting a remarkable series of talks to which Professor L., Rushbrook Wil-iams—one of the ablest thinkers on Indian affairs—has contributed a prefactory introduction comparable with Sir John Simon's own concise Broadcast talk on the Indian problem. "The Spectator" in a pioneer line of its own, has also helped in no small degree to broaden the basis of understanding. Beside such efforts the outbursts of impatient extremists, whether in England or India, appear to be merely empty petulance. In India itself the two great newspapers of Bombay and Calcutta "Times of india" and the Statesman"—are worthily help-in the same cause. The Indian press can with difficulty shake off the shackles of long years of traditional "suspicion and anti-government spleen. Journals like the Hindu' Madras and, the "Leader Allahabad which have usually' stood for a high standard of eri ticism are wholeheartedly trying to forward the process of mutual comprehension. Lord Irwin speech dissipates the notion that the way ahead is simple. Reports from India show that the new Viceroy will have to ex-excise all his qualities of for-Dearance, firmness and vision to steer the ship safely to the Conference harbour once more. Even now it would be rash to depend on Mr. Gandhi's sustained support. The ingrained tendency in Thdian politics to give heed most to the fatransigent to the exclusion of the genuine adherent to compromise and agreenient, must be a factor constantly endangering the truce. Yet the Government—expect soon} to announce the date of the resumption of the Round Table Conference, That is a definite gain. Will events in the next few weeks enable such progress to be made in India with the settlement of necessary preliminary points of difference that, the delegates can proceed to the task of filling in the details of the picture with a reasonable chance of success? The pregnant significance of that question should drive home to the most thoughtless critic the supreme necessity for heeding Lord 'Irwin's earnest appeal for calm and dispassionate approach,' to this great problem. definite outbreak of hostilities. Censorship is no novelty to the cable companies and the sulates who have special duties to perform under the regula-fons. The arrangements at the various consulates for facilitate ing the cabled correspondence of their respective nationals Shanghai should work smoothly. No anxiety appears to exist in official quarters; what has been done before can be done again. At the same time the commercial community cannot view the regulations with favour; even they are worked in the most expeditious manner, delays are likely to occur and' delays business cost money. It is to be hoped that the Government and the Consulates "concerned will Keep themselves closely touch with the needs of _commerce: for the importance of preserving the channels of trade as free as possible from obstructions are well-known to both, In times of special national emergency, a censorship is a normal precaution which any Government may be impelled to take. It must be with the greatest reluctance that it is adopted by a Government which, only recently, hi laid emphasis on its desire to relax the present rigid hold which it has assumed over the Press. Yet observers cannot fail to be a little uneasy. For a Government, anxious to establish world opin: ion in its favour, the censorship is a double-edged weapon. It may prevent the prompt dissem-_ ination of news and informa. tion considered to be detrimental to the Government's reputation. But this process of suppressing truth cannot be permanent. The mere annouticement to the world that a Government censorship exists immediately raises doubts. in the public mind. It is only necessary to quote the example of the late regime in Spain to prove that nemesis, slow but sure, effects the due adjustment of the claims of fact. If broad Prizeiples could be conveniently laid down in a few words, it might be said that a censorship should do all in its power to prevent the enemies of the Government from obtaining vital information and to preserve the morale of the country. It should, however, desist from withhold: ing facts however unpalatable and from discouraging honest and free expressions of opinion, except under compulsion of the clearest and direst need.

The regulations so closely conform to these obtainable in other countries where censor~ ship has been imposed in like circumstances that the Government may be taken to bear these principles in kind The policy of dragooning the Press, of insisting on the trans mission of nothing but highly one-sidedly pro-government messages to the exclusion of al! ex-' pressions of honest but contrary inion, has never been permanently successful, the.examples of Fascist Italy and Bolshevik Russia notwithstanding. In Shanghai the chief consideration is that of the preservation of the commercial ser-viees from undue delays. The argument that the Settlement should not be subjected to censorship, even if an appropriate emergency be declared to exist, cannot be supported on the basis fof the agreement between the Companies and the Chinese Government. It is to he hoped how-' ever that the cooperation of the Various authorities with the Chinese Government in this mat-_ ter will reduce, bureaucratic interference with legitimate and non-contentious commercial communications to the smallest possible margin.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account