The Archive · 1928

Incapacity of China's Minds

"F.D.Z." tries his best to state ease and brings forward political genius of her own, distinetive from the Western one, that out of the present chaos she will find her own salvation by following her own ways without necessarily embracing Western materialism and democracy, whose attempted trans-Plantation' on her soil proved an utter failure. In this very fact "P.D.2." triumphantly sees a proof that China's old civilization is reasserting itself," and in his naive belief he unconsciously confirms Senator Goft's diagnosis that the Chinese educated mind is blind to the fact that "China has been overtaken by the industrial revolution."

Let me remind "F.D.2." that his argument is a long exploded one. In Russia, from the time of Peter the Great's reforms up to the final wreck of the State, men, whose minds, like that of "P.D.Z." were burdened with the tyranny" of ancestral" dogmas—the Sia nophiles, as they styled themselves from the middle of last century-never ceased to repeat that Russia's way is not the Western way, that she does not require and. will never adopt Western democratic methods, arguments he uses, enough, only serve to. strength Senator Goft's verdict. He consciously. reveals Vineing fashion the of the even cultured Chinese to grasp their own political situa tion and duly to appreciate the true Western attitude towards the facts of China's present historical moment, the first place, "F.D.Z." commits the usual Chinese error of misconstruing unbiased Western of China's political and ife into the expression of a "deep-rooted feeling that one is inherently superior to another.' (viz Western to Chinese). In other for Goff as an all-round inferior race, denying them a place inthe civilized world, and. sentencing them to be governed by the West "as it governs Africa.!" "Incidentally, no such suggestion of politi ion palea violence 2 experience of her own pre-reform past, instead of having been forced into'a Western mould by Peter's will. Yet Russia, obeying the law of history, fatally followed the Western path of industrial develop: ment, and when she started the struggle to adapt her social structure to the new requirements she found herself mortally stricken by the course of her Asiatic inheritance, torn and shaken in frightful convulsions by the deadly poison of Asi Universal Way of Salvation Democracy is not the universal way. of salvation for nations; it is intended only for those who are fit for it. Like the Holy Communion, it benefits only the chosen ones and is damnation to the unworthy. No wonder it proved a failure in China with her 89 per cent. illiterate. nce of free citizen, to their social and! national" eapensbliea, "educated the spirit of mutual confucnes statement. Ax to the former Ca-operation, diseipli and. self the free Sacrifice forthe "com cause, even "F.D.2,." will dispute the fact that human races vastly differ from one another as to the levels of their cultural and political developments, some being classed as altogether inferior and barbarous or degenerate, some being respectively. superior or inferior to one another in. some characteristic manifestation of their racial genii, Differing Western Qualities Obviously China does not fit into this description, China's political and social back: wardness is partly the outcome of her industrial un development. But nonce of Western already started ialiam, which, of it '(except the majority of Chi bound to cause social chai Tt s0 happens, that, even amongst White Western races, some posses the faculty of producing individuals richly endowed with capacity for abstract and analytical thinking, oF a highly sensitive artistic tempers ment, whilst at the same tim lacking the genius of state may hip or the gift of collective effort, Others, on the other hand, possess the latter merits, but are"in wa of the former. "Now, I think it hi never entered Senator Goft's mind, in fact I may venture to assert, no truly enlightened Western mind would ever inwardly or openly. the Chinese as a race the injustice of ranking them at par with African tribes and refuse to pay due tribute to their great human-italian thinkers or to their individual and domestic virtues, What "F.D.2." typically fails to realize ix that Senator Goft's criti ism is solely and exclusively levelled the social and political sides of Chinese life; in other verds, at China's utter lack of statesmanly and collective genius. Sad, but true, China in this respect is not only "burdened with the tyranny of an organization made for it by ils ancestry," which fact is ade mitted by "P.D.Z,," but is prim cursed with her own and her conquerors' Asiatic inheritance, that very spirit of central Asia which Withers all sense of individual Tiberty, initiative and social inotinet, wherever its deadly breath poisons nations even outside Asia's geogra-Phical boundaries.

The Industrial Revolution This "F.D.Z." attempts to disprove in the ease of China by tell-dug: us that China possesses a Process started, and as long as a nation has not' yet fully awakened a3 a whole to political consciousness, in other words, is not yet ripe' for integral democratic self-rule, it is up to her educated, materially prosperous and political conscious minority, whatever their proportion may be, to assume the guardianship of the nation and by gradually educating the masses to a full realization of their citizenship to lead their fellow-citizens to share with them the burden of their responsibilities. Such is the histor-I task of a ruling class at any) given moment of a nation's history. And above all the rulers must be Leaders. If they fail in their task and selfishly abuse their power in their own immediate interests out thinking of the nation's future, the result is invariably the same: its name is chaos and destruction. Such was the fate of the vanished empires of old, such is the living instance of Russia of to-day.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account