The Archive · 1928

Court of Consuls

COUNCIL SUED BY CABARET

In the Court of Consuls, composed of Mr. &, S, Cunningham (Senior Consul) presiding, Sir Sidney Barton, and Major J. L. Isler, 8. H-Levy, owner of the La Gaité Cafe, on Tues day brought suit against the Shanghai Municipal Council for $0,000, and in his petition asked for injunction restraining the 8. M. C. from cutting off his electric light and from continuing the hindrance caused by a barbed wire fence, which they had built on Brenan Road in front of his premises. The Council since the petition was filed heve removed the wire and restored the electricity, Mr. K, E, Newman and Me. R.

Auxion de Ruff appeared for plaintiff and Messrs, G, H, Wright and J. E, Badeley represented the Municipal Council, According to plaintiffs petition, the Municipal Council ordered a barbed wire fence to be erected on, August 25, 1927, which extended considerable distance to either side of plaintiff's front gate and prevented the free and unhindered use of his premises; also that on August 20, the S.M.C. shut off his supply of electric current. His business was damaged, he contended, to the amount of $30,000.

In defendants' answer, filed on November 24, it is alleged—that Plaintiff violated his Keence con. Gitions, by remaining open after 2 'a.m.—when he should have clos and closing at 6 a.m., and that there was drunkenness and disorder on the premises and that clients entering or leaving the premises caused nuisance, The Council maintained their right to protect the rights Of soldiers quartered in Jessfield Park and other residents of the The Defendant's Functions of meeting this challenge in a Proper court, As a French protege, he could have been brought before the French Consular Court to. answer cha ges of having caused a nuisance, and the French law on this point, our of went on to say, is stricter than either British or American. His client now had a licence.

Mr, Wright—I must. interrupt Mr, Levy has no licence.

Mr. Newman—But he has a licence. T wish that you would not! interrupt, Mr. Wright—But, your Honours, has no licence.

Mr. Newman—Here it is (producing a Municipal document).

Mr. Wright—But that licence was fee anted for December, this is January.

Mr, Newman—That is a quibble. He could have a. licence, if he applied for one. It is too cold now and he does not want one.

"We will admit for the purpose of this ction," Me, Newnan went on to say, "that we are the biggest blackguards on the earth, but that not the point at all." Counsel then said that the S.M.C. had brought an action against Mr. Levy the French Consular Court for orating without a licence, the return date being 10 days later, August 27. Mr. Wright, inter: rupting, informed the Court that the charge referred to a breach of Without awaiting the tris Council shut. off the lights on 20, and built the barbed wire fence on August 26, extending 200 yards to either side of the premises, prolonging the line to 400 yards on the following day, when it beea known that patrons had crossed the Cafe. On the the day following the erection of the burped wire, counsel inferred that it appeared as though the French Consular Court showed their disapproval of the S. M, C.

by adjourning the heating, Plaintif('s reply (January 13, 1928) stated that placing the barbed wire shad been an unlawful act and a trespass against plaintiffs rights had been committed. The S.M.C, could have prosecuted Levy in the French Consular Court—they wore not a semi-judicial body, possessed with punitive rights; further that the S.M.C, had no ight to cut off the electric supply, excepting under a breach of that special contract, In the rejoinder, filed on Monday, wants denied' that they had exerted semi-judicial functions or were possessed of punitive powe and denied that they fused to abide by the decisions of the com petent Consular Court. In public interest it was necessary that this niuisaneo should have been stopped at once, Mx. Newman in his opening remarks—he spoke for nearly an hour =-taid that the principle was one the most important which a Court ever had to decide upon, one which, he insisted, concerned the legality of the ministrative body, usurp powers. He pointed out that in early Shanghai, the Committee of Ronds and Jetties (predecessors to the S.M.C.) maintained the right to inflict penalties. This was opposed by H. M. Consul, in particular, and other consuls as well. He then cited Article 23 of the Land Regulations, and pointed out that foreigners obtained their protection through this, which conferred extraterritorial rights.

Counsel intimated that opposing course] would attempt to emphasize the shortcomings of his client, but that should not affect their judgment as to the powers of the S.3f.C. His client was attempting to obtain redress arising from the misconduct of Council employees. Mr. Levy, might have the blackest character in Shanghai, but that should not affect the attitude of the Council, who had: not used the proper channels to obtain redress,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account