(kelly: & Wal thirty five, half fe, decided to commit his memories to print, and this interesting but uneven' book is the result. "It seems also to record the attainment of approximately half way towards "the goal so confidently set at twenty one, "Before thirty five—ohy_ haps potism of youth? T'was to have, Achieved the follow:
1 sp A-country place and a terra in town.
Married, Two sons. One dani chai of The author comments that it is of Pines found no place in this Li and that "humility played no part jin the compiling." Is he prepared for the remark that neither health, happiness, nor humility are very [conspicuous in his book? last page when the curtain over the half Jife that has passed, he {quotes Hesiod as saying' that halt is better than This may also be said of his book: the second half is. entertaining, interesting and thoughtful and one eventually closes the volume with regret; but the first half is dis-Appointing and the effort of getting through it puts the reader in'an unreceptive mood for what is worth reading tater on.
Cecil Roberts was born a pact, he became a journalist to earn "his ving, and he is now a lecturer and novelist, The novelist in him is responsible for the best parts of the book, and leaves: one with a distinct. wish to read all his novels. The lecturer brightens the book in places but guilty of annoying repetitions and such faults which, though unnoticed in a lecture, require editing before going to print.
The journalist must take most of the blame of the weak. patches the first half of the book: he given to "potted history" which JEould well have been omitted, to one Jor two biographical sketches which read. suspiciously like obituary notices, and occasionally to judgments which sound infallible but are in reality unjustifiable 'One is loth to blame the poet, but he must be responsible for' the theatrically florid. description of Venice by night with which the book opens. A timid reader may here easily frightened away by the profuse use of capital letters and Ralies, French, Italian, Latin. or German expressions, which. might merely" make him smile, if -encountered towards the chd, when the author is no longer a stranger.
'As a man, Mfr. Roberts has perhaps, as he' admits, something of the American about him. Read how hho, at the age of twenty-one o 30 obtained his first paid journalistic appointment. He applied toa newspaper box number advertising for @ dramatic and literary criti after a week he received a Teply:
"The suanager of the Liverpool out a considering my application.
49" that they' could Henry James, It is. trae had heard of him, prayed that "his breath might Spared for some hours more and dashed off to the public library. They had the complete works of Henry Hamelin fuel Nalumes._ Teele might expire at any Te was then three o'clock. By six clock "Thad. digested the wolve volumes, by eight o'clock I had umes, by eight o'clock I had pool at midnight."
This does not sound like a juvenile English poet. Nor do The succeeding pages tracing his descent from a fourteenth century Shropshire squire: this interlude might well have been omitted.
Mr. Roberts was _a war cor respondent from 1915 to 1918; at ur first with the fleet and then in France: his descriptions of a day with the Dover Patrol, of the sailing of a convoy from Milford Haven, of the march to the Rhine, and of the German H.Q. at Spa after the armistice are all good reading. He has nothing fresh to say on German atrocities or the lo Jellicoe-Beatty. controversy and these well-worn subjects should therefore have been left alone, In 1920 he became for atime editor of the "Nottingham Journal" and his chapter on this work is vealing to the layman and fills in some gaps_in "My—Northeliffe Diary:"" incidentally one wonders what Lord Northeljffe would have made of Cecil Roberts.
His descriptions of his four trips to the U.S.A. remind one vaguely of Brooke's "Letters from America." They leave however two suspicions jin the mind: the first, that people who undertake lecture tours America meet the treatment they deserve: the second, that this book was written with an eye on the American market.
One is grateful among other things for the rescue from oblivion of Byron's maiden speech in the House of Lords on behalf of th Nottingham rioters in 1812, for th sketch of Mrs. Victoria Balmoral Brown, the char lad episode of the Mexics the Dallas hotel resenting having his face smacked by is companion:
"He seized the lady by her, abund-od Cut short by the alert hotel-keeper, who loudly announced, as he, wrench:
them apart: "Say, Bo, this hotel's biedeaye for cockatoos To sum up, the book is well written and contains plenty of material, but most people will not want to' read it more than once—
[Bangkok is apparently a small place fand he soon locates Patricia, She living with some uncles. The entire family disappear, to turn up in England a little later enormously, wealthy. Of course the unscrupuc lous uncles have sacked a Siamese temple far up the river, and are living on the. proceeds of the. sale lof sacred jewels, so. when Dick: zs hho finds he has, with a family pursued. by a strange curse." Every time the fe rushed hibiscus. blossom appears there is a death in the familys, The it return to the East, where life supposedly. safe, only to. find themselves alternately" kidnapped. and. set free, singly and together, until they are able to restore the remaining jewels to. the. temple, Even then they face the wrath of Siamese doctor whose son was kkitled' by the uncles. But a loyal servant intercepts the blossom cone taining a deadly mosquito' and Phyllis is saved. Then they dite cover that she is only the adopted daughter of the long dead brother fof the family, and there is really curse upon her. 'The tale ends woodenly as it. began, but' the reading of it is almost bearable bee cause it contains all the devices of the stock Eastern story of revenge.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.