JCommon-Sense ano ie CuILD—A Elen for Freedom, "By Ethel Sane hin, Jarrolds Ltd, London, 6/~ Rank radicalism in the realm of child psychology we have to deal with here, Ail. modern scientific {theories of child training are thrown, overboard, but there is not a vestige Jof the good commonsense of our mothers and grandmothers left to take their place, The very title is, therefore, a misnomer, No doubt the author's abnormality could be traced by the pysch= to her own unhappy -child-T do not believe for a Imoment the first tenet of Credo" that "for nine out of ten people childhood is the unhappiest ime of life." plea for freedom on sumption is to deviate farther from the norm with each succeeding generalization, For one who professes to love chile dren and to understand them, to claim that most children are unhappy, that most of them hate their parents, that most of them indulge in secret sex habits, is to fatally prejudice her own case at the very outset, words be judged. Her attitude adults, except her friend, A. S. Neill, a few others of the Inow "free"' school movement and herself, is thus expressed: "Parents, Inurses'and teachers are the natural Jenemies of the child." Her~ cone Jdemmation of discipline for the child is complete: "Not merely do I believe that discipline nevoy' yet Idid anyone any good; T believe that it does positive harm." Hey revolt against religion and moral training reiterated: "Religion is bad for because it involves. moral This ie further amp fed by the statement: "If we want, keep the children healthy in soul, [we must guard against giving them Jany value whatever of good and bad, right and wrong."
Wat the thor has to any of education may be summarised in for' own words: *T0 have escaped jo good education is a very great blessing"; "Ideally, children should run wild' until thirteen or fourteen land then when they have outlived their childish interests, they may taught to read and write and do ple arithmetic." As to the arts they are merely the refuge of adults from unsatisfactory sex-life, compensations for the lack of faction in experience, That, I ven= ture to say, is a new interpretation lof the liberal arts. As to culture, the test is whether you like jazz well as Chopin, and Charlie Chaplin jas well as Goethe. The one good thing she has to suggest in this connection is the value for d lof foreign travel relationship among ferent nationalities.
But the one theme harped on ad nauseam is the sex theme, and she is as extreme here as elsewhere, Tt is in dealing with this subject that her lack of delicacy is most Japparent. If you would have more of this new psychology, which to me sheer twaddle, read'the book for yourself. Such extremism, course has its contradictions: OG tone moment the author says:. "I believe that the woman who cannot look after her own young herself
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.