The Archive · 1938

Must We Have War

Roman Catholic Record

To the Editor of the "NortH-Cumwa Dany News"

Sim;—Chesterton once refuted universal pessimism in a sentence: "If everything is bad, then' beer is bad a manifest absurdity rejected by all redblooded men!" In similar wise, we may Aay- if Fr. Lipman caused Jack Wanr-10-KNow to rub his eyes and scratch his head, "Fine, it was high time for him to wake up and start thinking." If he really wants to know, which I doubt, judging from his passionate, Savonarolic denunciation of canards which have been foisted upon his incredulity by second-rate propagandists for a life-time, I shall be glad to help him, arid point out useful sources that will aid him to re-educate himself on more rational, less apoplectic, lines. As he seems to be rather a Jumping Jack, hopping violently from country to country, I don't know whether he is a Turk massacred by the Crusaders, an Abyssinian "raped" by the Fascists, an Albigensian, a Basque, a Chinese Red, a Russian Communist, or merely an honest but underprivileged Belfaster. At any rate, let's hasten on to Lesson One.

Unless we take Voltaite's word for it. Jackie's Turks were planning to continue their "Holy War" of conquest and like Jackie overthrow the Holy Father and his Christian children and make all of Europe safe for Mohammedanism, when the Catholjes decided to make a little holy war of their own. It didn't succeed entirely; but at least it saved Christian Europe. And if your belligerent correspondent isn't expounding the Koran.to-day instead of the Bible, he has the Vicar of Christ and a lot of Catholic saints to thank for it, For interesting information about the- great Middle Ages, which I am sure Jackie naively thinks were impenetrably dark, consult Walsh's "The* Thirteenth, Greatest of Centurie: the century. of Dante, St. Francis of Assisi, the amazing cathedrals, the founding of the great universities at Oxford, Paris; the age of St. Thomas of Aquin who: is now beginning to create.a sensation at Harvard and the U. of Chicago.

When did the Vicar of Christ bless the armies that took part in the rape of Abyssinia? Please give the exact date, with -precise references. And please, please don't quote G. Salve-mini: Never believe a Guelph when speaking of a Ghibelline—if you know what I mean. The Vatican City is now an independent state. As long as the rights of the Church are respected the Pope, unless expressly called in by the parties in conflict to arbitrate, will not pass judgment on political quarrels. But where there is question of direct attacks on the Church's re~ ligious rights as in Russia, Germany and Spain—and formerly in Italy till Mussolini "admitted his mistake—the Pope speaks out fearlessly. These are potent historical facts which Mr. Jack can easily verify if he is really anxious to consult the original sources, instead, of believing what anti-papal propagandists have been shouting at him His sympathy for the Basques is a bit maudlin. Had they wisely listened to their bishops instead of throwing in their lot with 2 regime composed predominantly of radical Socialists, Communists, Syndicalists and Anarchists, a regime that had consistently violated in theory and in practise the fundamental princijes of liberty and democracy, that had attacked the traditional religion of Spain with incredible violence and destroyed within its area of control all the churches, religious objects and practically all the priests and Reli ous with unheard refinements of crucity: had they been wise in fighting for Spain instead of Russia, the last of Jackie's Soviet friends would already have been back~ home in Stalin's Poradise—or rather Purgatory. How a militant Christian can support Spanish communism and anarchy I leave your correspondent to explain in his own peculiar fashion.

Ås for the Albigenses: they condemned marriage, the union of the sexes, the use of meat and milk, civil oaths, the death penalty, obedience to a temporal authority. And so like the Basques, these other interesting friends of your fighting correspondent, got themselves into hot water. To get the attitude of Chinese Catholics regarding the present war, I advise Jackie to go to the sources again: consult Chinese Catholics, ask Msgr. Yupin who has been presenting the Chinese case strongly at Rome and elsewhere; ask the Catholic bishops of Hongkong and Shanghai; consult the radio discourse of the Apostolic Delegate, Msgr. Zanin, given some time ago from Hankow, before making asinine charges against Catholics. Actions, it may be noted, speak far louder than wọrds. If your correspondent will break down and confess exactly how much he has done for China during this crisis, he will doubtless see by comparison that Chinese Catholics have little to be ashamed of in their war record.

What private interpretation of "Christianity in a form emphasizing obedience to the teaching and example of Jesus Christ" may be expected of a wild-eyed Savonarola who espouses the cause of down-trodden Turks, Albigenses, and mild-mannered, soft-spoken Communists and Anarchists, is an intriguing prospect, Speak up, Jackie. But do keep your shirt on and your temperature down. Remember, the Catholic Church is built on the Rock of Peter and cannot be liquidated merely with a loud cry.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account