The Archive · 1931

ADDLED PUBLI CITY

Nov. 2.

It is to be hoped that Sir Miles Lampoon is satisfied with the manner in which the result of the Thorburn negotiations has been announced. If he is, he is easy to please. The situation now created, by which comment tlement appears before tails of the settlement are ily announced, forcibly calls to mind one of those slow motion pictures in reverse so often shown, on the cinematograph screen howe As the Chinese note will in due course be made public, this journal prefers to defer its examination of the settlement till then. On the publicity aspect of the case it may be timely and appropriate to comment. Would it be discreet to suggest that the Chinese Govexnment's note has been in the hands of the British Minister for more than a week? Under what, impression can the delayed publication of that fact be di fended? The Chinese Gover ment, surely, could not have expected that their official investigation of a case, which has stirred public " opinion in Great Britain as no such ca: has. done in recent years, could de concluded and its results communicated to the British Foreign Office without there being a full official statement on the subject. And, obviously, the more promptly such a statement were made the less chance there would be of inviting ill-informed criticism on the basis of conjectural reports. If the Chinese Government nourished any such notion, it was Six Miles Lampson's duty to disabuse them of it, It was, above all, incumdent of him, in his own inter to recognise that if Britis! diplomacy in China desired to regain the confidence of British opinion here and the powerful and growing reinforcement of that opinion in Great Britain, the enrlient possible, announce: ment should be officially mad may be urged that, as the London correspondent ' of this journal has telegraphed, one or! two minor points remain to be settled and that consequently no disclosure could be made. Sir Miles Lampson has before now had bitter experience of the unilateral system of publicity followed in Nanking. If the two Governments were of the opinion that a statement should be made only when every point had been cleared up, then there should have been adequate steps taken to prevent a premature announcement.

Tt was all the more neces sai to avoid an anti-climax of this Kind because British diplomacy was in need of all the acclamation which it could get here, The plain impression exists that, had it not been for the attention drawn to the Thorburn case in the Press and by public opinion carefully and restrainedly marshalled, that case would have been num-dered among the other unsolved mysteries which have agitated the British community from time to time in recent years. In public life the creation of an impression is far more important and effective than removing a misapprehension. All the way along the British Minister has put himself in the - position of being spurred by some another to action in this case. This may be—possibly is—an unfair representation of his} actions. It would be idle to deny that it has obtained considerable colour from the chronological view of events. Now, when he has an opportunity of setting himself right with the public, he entirely miases it, by permitting the case to be expounded in the light of an "addled publicity. Some! novelists give the misunderstood man the halo of the hero. In veal life, with its highly developed means of communication, such sympathy is withheld. The lady who "wept in silence and was Dido dumb" would be laughed at in these days when. every actress has her publicity agent. This crudely blunt statement of the case for better use of the recognised organs of public opinion deserves careful consideration. Tt is not only in regard to the Thorburn murder that the British community has been' sorely puzzled over the aims and objects of diplomatic discussions. The telegrams published yesterday showed that Lord Lloyd has made the definite assertion that some form of an Extrality Treaty has been initialled by Sir Miles Lampson. 'This report has been current for' some weeks here and in London. Those who are charged with the duty of guiding public opinion can satisfactorily perform it no more on the basis of popular gossip than on reliable information confidentially conveyed. During the past few months there has been correspondence between the Hankow British Chamber of Commerce and the British Minister on the proposals [for the abolition of Extrality. In the course of that correspondence it was baldly stated that the Shanghai British Chamber of Commerce had, through certain of its representatives, been made confidentially aware of the nature of the proposal Yet Hankow British merchants, who, in point of fact, might be more seriously affected, were not let into the secret. This journal is convinced that the British Government have no intention of authorising acceptance of proposals which would make the position of British residents in China impossible. But it must be recognised that almost the only information on which the public have to proceed is the fact that the - Chinese Government have decreed the abolition of Extraterritoriality on January Ist next—in defiance, let it be noted, of Treaty obligations. The idea that a new Treaty is to be hastily initialed in or mainly, to extricate the Chinese Government from an untenable position seems too fantastic: for belief. Yet it actually has amed currency. The argument lat the new arrangements contain safeguards disposing of all apprehension may be. valid. Unless the light of publicity be thrown upon them, the value of those safeguards is likely to be questioned. Dismissing the Thorburn affair, it is sufficient surely to urge that a Government. which cannot inflict punishment on any of a mob of three thousand students who invade the Foreign Office and beat up the Foreign Minister so that his resignation has follow, must not complain if their ability to enforce th machinery of proper legal procedure ju respect of foreigners ig subjected to severe scrutiny.

This is written in complete sympathy with the Chinese Government and their difficulties It is no part of a friend to encourage pretensions to duty which cannot be discharged. At! the present time, when the victory won at Geneva requires consolidation, the Government are apparently powerless to! prevent a rapid deterioration in their position, by reason of the travagant absurdities of the anti-Japanese boycotters. Thus, on the one hand, there is rec Jess use of the Press for bolstering up claims which cannot be logically substantiated. On the other, there is a dignified but inept' silence which positively invites the continuance of misunderstanding. The British public have a right to know exactly how the Government propoze to deal with this question of Extrality. It is dangerous to Tet the matter drift and then, on January 1, 1932, find that calcula-\ions have been upset. There is not necessarily a tack of confidence in the British Minister, but his methods of publicity have not tended to encourage

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account