The Archive · 1931

Surrender Unwarranted by Conditions

London, Oct, 28.

'The negotiations which kate been proceeding for some time between the British and Chinese governments with reference to the fate of a British subject, Bfr. John Thorbarn, are approaching completion. Reuter's Keeney learns that the' Foreign Office has received a despatch from the: British Minister in China, 8 Miles Lampson, which is understood to afford a basis for the settlement, of the affair.

Oct, 81, the League of Nations Council when the Manchurian affair was discussed, The vernacular papers are becoming indignant towards Britain, declaring she is trying to China's favour.

Local radio broadcasts are spreading all sorts of sensational rumours individual, Japanese well-disposed Britain and even

towards Britain express themselves bitterly disappointed over what is described as her unfriendly attitude towards Japan.

The newspapers to-day again give Prominence to the Thorburn case and there is very pungent criticism of what is regarded as the inability] of the Chinese Government to maintain law and order.

In a letter to "The Times," Lord Lloyd, the former High Commis sioner of Egypt and the Sudan, re ferring to the agreement which it is understood Sir Miles Lampson negotiated with Dr. C. T. Wa former Chinese Foreign Minister, cites the Thorburn case as a reason why extraterritorial rights. should be abolished, at any rate until Parliament has been given an opportunity to review the whole question, the 'Thorburn ease are' based. upon comments. of on

the Chinese report of the official investigation into Thorburn's disappearance. Tt ts understood. that this. Report. states that Thorburn, twhen halted by. troops in. Soochow: Grew his revolver and. shot. two Soldiers. He was then over-powered ud, after being paraded through The "Asahi," regarded as a level headed organ, to-day editorially dis. courses on the "conspicuously and even maliciously unfriendly attitude which the British delegate assumed towards Japan in the League Coun-sil's session," and gloomily "the firm AngloJapanese of 30 years' standing. th ticker and extinguish,"—Reuter, Profound Regrets of the Chinese Commenting on the ease, the "China Times" expresses the' Chi: nese people's profound regret the unhappy. incident, but states that deceased was also to blame for his defiance of the gendarmes. While it is the duty of the Government to deal severely with the per-ons responsible for Mr. Thorburn's death, it is to be earnestly hoped that both the Chinese and) British Governments will regard the incident as a "local affair" maintain the present friendl tions between China and the journal states, position of the' body, it still remains a mystery.

The "News Chronicle" states that the alarming feature of the abomin. able murder is not merely that suck fan outrage should be possible, but that it is a0 difficult to suggest any really adequate measures for, the protection of the of. British nationals against such attacks.

"The best that can be hoped for," says the paper, "is that Chinese! Rationalists with the menace from span before their eyes will realise! in time the peril to which such murders expose thei be strong enough to possible in the future'

Tu his letter to "The Times," Lord Lloyd cites the general understanding that Sir Miles Lampson, the British Minister to China, has re cently negotiated a treaty' sith the]

nese Foreign Minister under Britons will be finally de-of the protection of Consular] Jurisdiction.

He declares it to be the unanimous opinion and the urgent, plea of} British communities ju China" that such treaty should be concluded uni ite conditions have been sub-itted to, and approved Hament, Lord Lloyd, in support of his contention, quotes the Thorburn case and says the prospect of any stable and effects Central Government 1g. established in China is ex tremely remote.

He also attributes the difficulties with Japan tothe. absence of a Government in China which is able for'mmintain order and' protest. the Wcrests of foreigners and, Sally, points to the fact that the Foreige Sinister, with, whom Sir ales Lampson has "been negotiating in Nantine, has now resigned from the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account