Oct. 16.
Some few days ago we published on this page a contributed article prompted by the case of 4 man who had deliberately broken a window, not for theft, but in order to get board and lodging in gaol, The writer of that article suggested that the charitable societies might put little money in the hands of the police for immediate relief in eases occurring late at night. From what we have since heard, the Cha ization Society does not share the views of the writer whom we have been quoting. Their opinion, the outcome of much bitter experience, is that men who break windows in order to be kept in gaol at the community's expense might have done a great many other things before being reduced to this extremity and in most cases have actually been given plenty of chances of keeping themselves. Which brings us back once more to the old exhortation so often expressed in these pages, that people should not give 2 they know nothing of the recipient's antecedents without previous reference to the C.0.S. and that charity in such cases can only fruitfully be done through the organized agencies.
There remains, however, the question originally asked by the writer quoted above, What are these men to do? We cannot help thinking that the question should rather be, What can be done with them? That there are many cases of genuine il! luck, of employment lost through bad trade or ill health, no one would deny for a moment. But we think it would be safe to say that in the majority of these instances help can be and is given with good result, The man helped is only anxious ty become self-supporting again. Experience, however, forces us all to the conclusion that there are people whom it appears simply impossible to help. Jobs are found for them again and again, but they never keep them. They will not work and so long as they can pick up a living by devices that one can scarcely do not find them selves compelled to make an effort. They appear to have obsoletely no moral sense and to this extent might be classed 23 mentally deficient, but the deficiency is not acute enough to get them put under restraint. Several years ago the Council established a work shelter where a lodging for the night and breakfast are always obtainable.
But as a cet demanded in the mornin, jolter has never been popular with the drifters, who remain a real and constant problem to Shanghai, with the added acuteness of the dislike which all Westerners rust feel for seeing one of their own race "go under" in Asia, But as nobody seems to feel this less, or to bother Jess about stopping the descent, than the drifter. himself, we come back to the question, What can be done with then?"
In Norway and Sweden, understand, possibly in other, countries as: well, persons who will not work are not allowed to loaf about Jiving upon the com munity. After due warning, they are put into labour colonies, which not only force them to work for a livelihood, but, more importantly; endeavour by expert means to revive in them their self-respect, with so muck success, we have read, that the inmates after a certain period of detention go out to find work as free men, Something of the same kind is undoubtedly needed in Shanghai and by the nature of it the expense should not be so great as to stay the Municipat Council from establishing it, Besides, it would very soon be Khown along the China coast that drifters were not tolerated in Shanghai and they would keep away. Such an institution would, of course, be sele without the ce-operation of all the consular courts; but we cannot imagine that, if individually approached by the Council, the consuls would make any diffe culty about undertaking to send to the Inbour colony the: who ought to go there, The me mates would, of course, be under detention, but at stated periods they would be free to look for work on their own account; and a good character earned in the labour colony should be a help in finding it, The additional question will occur to all who interested in such matte fof the women who are to be classed as mentally deficient, though not far enotigh to ware~ rant their being put into asylum. But this is too large. a subject for the present article, That it needs consideration and remedy, we fear there is no doubt. For the moment, it may. be enough to deal with the men who could work but won't, and for whom it is urgently necessary to find a way of bringing them to their sense
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.