On Dec. 9, the case of Ezxal Abdullah Barden y. Liza Barden ame up on a motion before Judge Sir Peter Grain, brought by. the Plaintiff, for an' order to appoint administrators and receivers to the estate of the late Silas Har-oon, pendente lite and, after a long' and protracted "hearing but was dismissed, with costs, Mir, M, Resder Harris appeared Mr, G. H, Wright and Mr. "John support of the motion hoist McNeill, representing the testateix, Elza Barden, posed the applica tion.
opening, Mr, Harris read the statement. of claim. which asked that probate of the will of the deceased should be revoked, on the rounds that "At the time of his death the deceased was a Jew and citizen of ena, having been born in Baghdad, and had been granted Bi Consular and diplomatic pea, to the Treaty of Alliance tween Great Britain and fra:
The deceased wav not a British subject; deceased by his "pretended will purported to leave the se hole of his property to the defendant,"
Chinese citizen, xi appointed her sole executrix, and That by the laws of Iraq a testator's will can only cover. one third of the property of the testa-for, and a will in favour of one belt is not valid, without the con: sent of the Yemaining. cosh a legatee of different fromthe ceatator cannot. inherit; "This. application" said Harris, "is made under the Court of Probate Act of 1867, sec. 70. In this cuse the plaintiff' knows very little more about the estate at the present time than the man in the street, who has seen reports of its value in the ordinary newspapers, find who has known the deceased during his life time as a very rich nan, ai J not possible for him to furnish at the p sent time, those particulars which he would Tike to furnish, but it ts clear that some independent person should be appointed, charged with the duty to collecting' the vent, renewing leases, fand doing other matters: necessary tothe administration of the estat, pending the hearing of the trial of the action, I submit that such an Appointment can prejudice "nobody at all, but the plaintiff" might be prejudiced if no, such appointment {nade as it might lead to waste of the estate, submit that" th order asked for should be" made find that, these two persona (name ed) should be appointed as recei 3 "and. administrators.
ate, pending the heating of_this fection! And. that they be ordered furnish such security as the Regis.
mig Wright, in' reply a Landy thie eaten a which can be disposed ther ency and airy fashion sug gested by my learned friend. Tam xoing to satisfy your Lordship that this is @ frivolous application, and is, probably. unique inthe "annals of Retions in the Probate. Division of this Court, {want your lordship to bear that factor in mind, when you ave listening to ae, that "this an action in the Probate Divi son." Tsay" it is teivoious, because the''plaintit asks your lotdebip to Aispassess the defendant, who i the widow, sole. beneficiary and sole executrix under the will of the Into Mr. Barden, and to whom a fis' Court, from the Position of rant. of probate as geanten
having the care' and management of tie estate which ie ae preseat in for hands without "alleging. any food grounds whatsoever: My lear id. friend. acorns to assume "alco that, so far as her present position Jas executrix is concerned, she is Fonetus officio. If your lordship has not now, you will later on, have! grave dovbis as to the bona fides this action "generally.
'In order to, succeed the plainiff must show to your lordship that there are some good for the appointment: that there some necessity for it, and, £0. far grounds whatever' have' been Shown, Why" is it necessary that the should be turned out of the control and" management? Mrs. Hardoon has, always assisted "her husband in the management of the estate, and stil manages. it, A Very strong case has got to be Tiade, out for the appointment of an administrator pendente lite.
'The plaintiff obtained from the Registrar an order that the grant of probate issued to her shoutd Qeposited in the Registry result of a claim that the deceased mentally' incapable. of mak-Ing: a. wil and/or wag acting under undue influence." Your lordship Will appreciate what a serious delegation that is to make, yet December 1, a statement of claim filed, and the first cause of action velating to those two rounds is completely abandoned, 'T'am entitled to ask your lord:
for judgment on that cause fof action. The reason is obvious why it has been abandoned.
There never were any grounds to support such a cause of action, and I'say that the grant of probate has no right to be in the Registry at all: it should be handed out. In Taking those allegations, the plain-HHT has sworn an affidavit in Whien he didn't samson information and belief, but he swore positively that the late Mr. Barden was mentally incapable of making a will and/or was acting under undue influence, and he has brought upon himself fall. the penalties of & prosecution for perjury. will appreciate what an outrageous Not only, that, my lord. You id scandalous thing it is to make allegations of that nature against this. unfortunate) widow—a more devoted couple never lived Shanghai—to say that she exerjgised undue influence over her liv band to make a will in her favour thathe was mentally in; ble of making a. will.
There is another matter must refer to, and that is the question of costs and expenses. The applicant is- man of no occupation, and he is a man without any means: say that because he attempted to sue informa paupers. He has lose by this action, by. thi application, Obviously, it outside people are" appointed "a: ministrators, they entitled to commission on what they collect, which may become a big sum. this action fails, my lord, no costs recovered from the
appointing. this. administrator, if, ad! te whole of the eluding the' commission, would have' to be boone by my cent of of heron, pocket" What belter person could your lordship. suggest Eo"look after the management "of the estate than Mrs, Hatdoon? She Knows it inside out, and has a find. ficient staff'to carry Tinnagentent of the estate. Cleatiyy lord, the sole beneftary is the Fey best. person tov select. What does ig done in her own inter est, and what is in her own' inter-cat ig, inthe interpats of the Copious quotations were mad from legal text books by both fie heaving and' at the cone of counsel's speeches, "his fordship® proceeded fo sur thi fs &'notice of motion, asking the Court to appoint certain people as, administrators of this tate.
vent has been {ssued, which hae een since, amended, and. further ended bythe. "Statement of The original reason for lodging fa caveat has more or less. dis appeared, and a new reason has now sprung up. It ma} be a bona fide prayed for: I have power to refuse Revand T think the. law, as. Laid down in the text book of" Mortimer, published in 1927, is the law tosays, it doesn't follow matter of course, where on is pending, that the Probate Division is bound to make an order for administrators" pendente 'Tite: goes on, further, to state, as a eneral law, that' the applicant, is, Fequired to thow some necessity for the granting of the Order—that it [s necessary for. the preservation of the estate—for "the receipt of rent ts—paymient of interest or of dividends on shares they may become due, and that At and proper person is in @ posi tion to discharge those duties now.
"Mrs, Barden has taken that fact, but Mr.
States that she-has been managing
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.