meeting to show one single shred of evidence in favour of prolonging the orchestra, "Poisoned Economies"
In preparation for proposing this amendment, he had interviewed a number of prominent ratepayers, and one of them, who, if he had as many votes as he had interests, would be able to dominate the vote, had described the orchestra as ridiculous.
He had visited one of Shanghai's "political wizards", and had been told that it was only necessary to raise the point to free the Council from the orchestra incubus which had poisoned its economies and impaired its efficiency."
As a small item—a straw in the wind—Mr. Stewart remarked that on January 1, 1937, the orchestra had music valued at $584.41; at the end of the year the value of the music still $584.41, yet during the year $1,453 had been spent on new music. What had happened to this $1,453 Probably no one would ever know.
In a similar way he referred to the entries dealing with the value of instruments, and then compared the orchestra report with that of the Municipal Advocate. The latter showed 94,000 cases prosecuted, 95 per cent, of which were successful. The staff consisted of one foreign advocate and several assistant advocates, and the cost of the department was under 000, which represented a cost of a little over $1.50 a case.
Comparing this with the orchestra he noted that the conductor had appeared in 1937 fifty times, which at the rate of his salary meant a cost of $264 a performance, for directing 45 musicians for about two hours, He compared this unfavourably with the salary paid to the Chief Jailer in War Road Jail, who had 6,000 convicts to look after, yet was paid less, "Employees' Grievance"
He alleged that the cost of the orchestra was a grievance among the employees of the Council who had received reductions in pay—that the Council was economizing with one hand and passing out a gigantic extravagance on the other—a squeeze on the small salaries which had resulted in a drop in morale in all departments.
What the Settlement needed, said Mr. Stewart, was a grand jury or a supreme court or some similar body to act as advisors to the Council. The existence of such a body would prevent wild-eyed schemes for squandering money from every being born, He. suggested that the British Chamber of Commerce would fulfil this function effectively Mr. Stewart criticized the annual report, which he said gave the minimum of vital information in the maximum of time. Its value could be realized by the fact that, though the had announced its willingness to send gratis copies of the report to those ratepayers who applied for them, only twenty had applied.
In concluding a speech which on several occasions had aroused amusement and applause from the meeting, Mr. Stewart strongly criticized the economies in the police, which he said were a risk to the public safety; he dealt with the argument that disbandment of the orchestra would cause unemployment; and answered the argument that the orchestra was a cultural institution of value but suggesting that, in the light of recent events, there might be a Guestion whether Shanghai could claim to be even civilized. Finally he said that the ratepayers, in endorse ing the expenditure for the orchestra, might well be encouraging the Council to spend in other directions, and raise the rates even to the height cient reason for abandoning the archestra, Mr. Stewart had hinted that Council officers had tried to throw dust in the eyes of the Council. If that were the case it meant that the Councillors were asses not fit to hold the positions they held, and that was not so. On the contrary, the ratepayers owed a debt to the Council for their work. Police efficiency he maintained, was now 100 per cent-greater that it was ten years ago.
Arguments that reductions in the staff of departments were good rea~ sans for the abolition of the orchestra were unsound, since there was no object in keeping on men when there was no work for them to do, and it. would be easy to engage suitable men when there was work to be done. With regard to the orchestra the position was different. The orchestra had taken 57 years to build up and would be most difficult to reconstruct if it were dispersed. He concluded by describing the amendment as a display of the spirit of defeatism, and appealed for its rejection.
"Wanton and Unnecessary"
Mr. E. F. Harris described the or~ chestra as "one of the greatest cultural assets east of Suez" and compared the amendment advocating its destruction to the "wanton and unnecessary" destruction of the educational and cultural institutions round Shanghai which had been a feature of the hostilities. Most members of the orchestra also played in the Brass Band, he went on to say, while the orchestra also had educational value; enabled Shanghai to hear world famous musicians as they passed through; gave pleasure to thousands in the parks; and had proved an aid in charity productions, Dealing with Mr. Stewart's arguments, Mr. Harris remarked that Mr. Stewart had given the impression that he was a cost accountant. Mr. Harris had looked him up in the Hong List and found that he was "a man who mends radios." His arguments he described as rubbish, The second part of the amendment—that all Council funds be expended only on the basis of imperative necessity—meant that the Council would not be allowed to purchase even one library book, It might mean that the parks would have to be closed, since fresh air, though a necessity, could be had on the streets. He said that the amendment shackled the Council and meant that the community had no confidence in it. If adopted, it would create an intolerable position. mittee of the Or ra, written by the Acting French Consul-General, M. Auge. In this letter Mr. Auge Sai "In the event of these suggestions (the weekly concert) receiving the ap-Proval of your committee, I would be in a position to assure you that a sum of $20,000 would be available in order to contribute towards the maintenance expenses of the Municipal Orchestra, Without taking into consideration the sum of $2,400 formerly allocated...... The envisaged participation would naturally be maintained only in the event of the Municipal Council of the International Settlement continuing to include the cost of the orchestra in its annual. budget."
Mr. Harris finished up by referring to the amendment as panic legislation, and hoped that the proposer and' seconder would be moved to withdraw it, Otherwise, he said, it should be defeated by a large majority.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.