The Archive · 1937

Submission to Judgment

The statement of claim further alleged in its seventh and eighth paragraphs that the lease from the Central" Realty Company to the Shanghai Land & Finance Company had been entered into fraudulently with intent to defeat the—plaintit's rights under the mortgage and that the defendant company had since the Ante of its incorporation wrongfully fond in derogation of the plaintitrs Fights collected the rents from the tenants of the buildings upon the tot and had prevented the plaintiff from Collecting them. These allegations were denied in the defence, but ino letter of October 15, 1996, inevertheless, the defendant company und ook, in consideration of the plaintiff company agreeing 10. an adjournament sine die of the hearing fixed (or the following day, to deliver up full possession of the land and buildings find to instruct the tenants to pay their rents to the plaintiff, and at the hearing on February 16 last submitted to judgment in the terms of the claim. The question of the damages sustained by the plaintif® company was post-'Poned to the taking of on account of the rents collected by the defendant company and. that is the only question now before me. In supe port of the allegation of fraud ligainst the defendant company translations of the judgments of - the Chinese Courts, as admitted former counsel for the defendant, were put in without objection. In these respectively, the First Special District Court held that there was ground for the plsintif's allegation that the lease was a collusive and false declaration" of intention. con-rived to defeat the creditors"; the first Court of Appeal that "the transection including the lease indicated m usual trick with Intent to damage - the right of the respondents," and the Supreme Court that "the lease was a false declaration of intention with which to evade be the respondents' fexereise "of the Fight of mortgage."

It is on these mech findings of the Chinese Courts alone} that the plaintiffs claim to damages is based, and the question which T have to consider is how far, if at all, the findings are admissible evidence in this Court,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account