The Archive · 1937

PROSAIC PERTINENCE

Whether Japan is able to revise her present decision to stand aloof from the Nine Power Conference at Brussels or, as unfortunately seems more probable, will persist in abstention from that form of international co-opera tion, it is necessary to put on record the circumstances in which her decision is being taken. An instrument to which she with eight other nations is a party has been framed with the declared object of safeguarding the integrity of China and so securing that Far Eastern stability on which Japan properly sets store. Events have aroused certain apprehensions that the obligations of the Treaty in question have been neglected or are in danger of being ignored. There is prima facie evidence of the justification for that view in the statements of Japanese representatives themselves, to go no further. It is true, of course, that the League of Nations which has had under consideration specific data on which a protest has been formulated against Japanese policy and actions has been moved to come to certain conclusions unpalatable to Japan. It is equally true that the League, recognizing the defects of its present composition, has for the time being preferred to leave the matter in the hands of the signatories of the Nine Power Pact who might be expected to command Japan's co-opera tion since she is one of them, albeit no longer a member of the League. The League has, however, not been the direct convener of the Conference which takes its origin from the motion of the President of the United States of America, one of the nine signatories, It has been expressly declared that the Conference approaches the issue in no spirit of censoriousness. No member is to be asked to stand in a white sheet or will be invited to mount a pedestal of oppressive sanctity. The immediate problem is the existence of a state of war which has paralyzed one of the most important of Far Eastern countries and involved millions in the misery of slaughter and desolation. Beside that concrete fact discussion of responsibility or any attempt to apportion blame becomes merely a dilletante study of the abstract. The practical service which the Conference is charged to perform is that of devising a means for bringing so parlous a state of things to an early conclusion, Its members do not conceal their feeling that, without Japanese ce-operation, the task may prove to be impossible. That, at any rate, is the primary motive of their renewing the invitation which Japan is now considering.

It would be absurd to pretend to be surprised that so much persuasion has to be employed, or that even then it may fail, to ensure what, in the private life of an ordinary citizen, would be regarded as a routine act of courtesy among business associates. Japan whether she likes it or not, is a business associate of the other eight powers and the problem set for their common handling affects them all in greater or less degree. Although, for reasons which seem good to her, Japan has unilaterally taken measures to adjust her relations with China, the fact remains that those measures—justifiable or otherwise radically affect the interests of her associates and, therefore, their relations with China and Japan herself. It is not unreasonable for Japan to be asked to enter into a conference with those intimately and juristically concerned with these developments if only to facilitate the statement of her policy in the manner which international usage and courtesy alike demand. Japan has consistently maintained that her policy in China has been framed and carried out with the object of contributing toward peace and Far Eastern stability. She has shown considerable anxiety over what she imagines to be an unfair hostility to her present actions. Can she avoid accepting the opportunity now offered and, yet, expect the world to believe that her case cannot be assailed? Whatever resentment she may feel against the League. she has.no justification for accusing the Brussels Conference of bias or lack of consideration for her dignity.

It is to be feared that Japanese statesmen and those who are disposed to applaud their obduracy are blind to the fundamental issues which the present crisis has directly raised. The persistence with which Japanese apologists endeavour to base the justification for the invasion of China on the delinquencies of this or that section of the Chinese Government, on the alleged failure of that Gover: ment to develop a policy compatible with Japanese aspirations or on its slowness in asserting its national authority, seems to be deliberately inviting disillusionment when the judgment of sober opinion is sought, The present state of the world has driven home the lesson that comity among nations cannot be preserved unless a determined effort be made to bring them back to the same simple principles on which the relations between individuals are based, Those principles demand some sort of assurance that the pledge and the plighted word can be reliably invoked. Human weakness is such that fidelity to counsels of perfection often falters, but human relationships depend in the last resort on a general recognition of the rectitude of those counsels and a general endeavour to keep faith as between man and man, The substitution of other standards in the world to-day has been so disastrous that the conscience of civilization is dulled. That has disquietened statesmen who can still keep balanced minds and who still refuse to despair of their generation. It may be that in a corporate discussion of this problem errors have to be confessed or at least recognized. Yet that is not the chief consideration for practical men. They surely are concerned with the prosaic pertinence of securing to the nation as to the individual that freedom which is the birthright of humanity—a freedom not destructive of other liberties or intrusive on other polities whatever the pretext may be. Japan has admittedly called in question the right by arms to impose on China her will without recourse to the considered judgment of her colleagues in international ce-operation, If she refuses to respond to the desire for her presence in considering the issues involved on the basis of equality, she will be assuming a responsibility which one day may prove irksome and productive of unavailing regret.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account