March 7.
Mr. T. V. Soong has been completely candid. The Generals of the various Chinese armies know exactly what the Finance Mi ter thinks of their military deficiency. In particular North. jem soldiers are reminded that patriotism and some degree of fervour are required to conduct Jevew a moderate defence against jo modern army. It is now revealed that Mr. Soong, after his recent trip to Jehol, became painfully conscious of the defects of the forces entrusted with the defence of that Province. He maintains that, even so, the gesture of defence, slight' as it was, was justified." It certainly has made it impossible for any Chinese apologist, however, jeestatic, to be under illusions regarding the relative merits of the Chinese and Japanese troops—or rather of the organisations paign. against an enemy force, albeit natural and not human, is difficult, therefore; to under-every. month during which this dispute has lasted. Possibly those whom Sir John again endeavoured to instruct in the stand why he and his colleagues reali of the.; situation are /were unable to impress upon the Jobsessed by experience with the country the plain facts of the [trade unionists? lack of those qualities in tholi strike weapon, if a strike is launched but military machine fondly expected f ound to be ineffective, it is to trip up, if not entirely to withdrawn and nothing very delay, the advancing Japanese serious happens except the loss forces. Apparently the view|of trade union money and the was that the lesson could be inflictionof @ certain damage to taught only by actual experience. the industry. concerned.
Both That view must be accepted as,|disasters are usually remediable at any rate, coming from. one without much rouble or delay. who ought to be able to judge The penalty which a nation runs the weaknesses of Chinese politi-] the isk of incurring, if it auical thought. Tt is hardly endorse thouses the imposition of a by those who are under the sanction against another nation impression that the Sound and {ai ud it fails to achieve the desired of Chinese bank- obj ject, is not merely a loss of fers would have been reliably prestige but, almost certainly, ex-enlisted by the Government in posure to the obligation to make support of the candour now war. The contention that, if all ortheoming from the Finance|nations agreed to apply sane-ister, tions, this danger would be This is said in no spirit of negligible cannot be regarded carping criticism but with the Practical.
To begin with, the object of recording firm ap-|¥i isks incurred by all would be redation of Mr. Song's bold-by no means equal.
More imness. If his views are taken to portant still, a nation responsible heart and not made the text for lor the proper diplomatic con- J reciminatory aspersions on his duct of its international relation, patriotism, it is possible to hope ships cannot gamble on "iff that a really combined effort' will {a1 ind "ans." Once it decides thr, eliminate factors which might fed, if naturally anxious. have militated against limitation The responsibilities now rest-of the movements of Japanese ing on the Government at Nan-troops. This journal has never king are heavy. Sympathy can-concealed the view that, political-Rot be withheld by those who ly and tactically, even a show of resistance in Jehol was a mi have appreciated the cruelty of the dilemma in which that Gov-take—an understandable ernment has been placed. Men take but mainly in the light lof ability and resource find in of theoretical notions of pre-the extremity of defeat inspira-stage. So long as the offic tion for recovery. It is one of policy of the Government. wi the most steadfast qualities in to encourage the idea of re-human nature. Jehol presents sistance it was impossible for least this opportunity: fantasy the commentator to expound can be withdrawn.from con-fully the reasons for holding ion of its immediate fate. that an unusually. vain effort Realities can be given their due. was "being. attempted Lack There is no need for the Govern-of funds and, within certain ment of China to waste time over self-reproach. It would be fatal would not of themselves dictate limits, inferiority in auipment, for it to ruminate over wrongs inaction. The pivotal require. which it cannot redress. By ments were unity of purpose and determined concentration of all loyalty to that purpose. No its energies on. the elementary blame can be attached to the problem of cutting losses, it can Japanese for exploiting the its self-respect and possibilities of an elaborate spy actually lay the foundations of system, linked up with the offer better national structure. The of financial inducements to those first step must be to liquidate who wore ready to desert to the its relations with Japan. Diplo-winning side at the appropriate matic contact has not been moment. In politics and broken but it requires to be diplomacy the process of keep-promptly intensified. ing a foot in both camps can be that some show of resistance sometimes indefinitely prolonged, will secure a more advantageous Once the test of military opera-settlement has again been tested tions ix applied that "process and refuted. Japan has solid becomes a bluff which sooner or reasons for desiring to make the ter has to be called, process as easy The significant feature ong as her acti m is in events in the North during the essence safeguarded. Her trade ast few months has not been the relations with China of them-desperate effort of the local selves provide inducement for thorities to keep in touch with coming to terms. The situation Nanking and to maintain an demands from both, as from all attitude of resistance in Jehol. concerned, the elimination of the Ht has rather been found in the factor of resentment or reproach marked aloofness of two im-43 a basis of policy. If only beportant military leaders: General cause Chinese and Japanese Chiang Kai-shek and General have to work side by' side, Man Fu-chu. The Generalissimo have to trade with each other may be criticised for not having and, in so doing, have to more definitely used the weight Preserve a common amity with of his expert knowledge to insist the nations represented in. their the hopelessness of the midst, this practical frame of plan for opposing Japan's clock. mind is to be commended. It work advance. Ho can at least may be unpalatable to one side argue that he refrained from or the other to have to forego uiving personal endorsement to the luxury of justifying its that plan, Anywhere else his Fespective policy. That arid studied absorption in the com-occupation should give place to munist campaign for the last an eager eye on the future. year would have been regarded is not too much to say that the plainest of plain hints. [Japan's own interests will incline General Han Fucchu, lately her to be receptive of proposals strengthened in his command of for strengthening the position of Shantung, has maintained a Chinese authorities who are precorrect devotion to his provincial pared to shoulder the pressing duties. He has shown burdens of reconstruction and: tendency to give Japanese policy rehabilitation in a spirit of real in Jehol any colour of sympathy. statesmanship. Even the bit-He has contented himself howterest critics of the Government ever with keeping Shantung free at Nanking cannot deny to it from the turmoil in the neigh-the credit of having manfully Vouring provinces. Having retackled appalling—difficulties gard to the terrain and making which would have taxed the] all allowances for the defects of Yesources and skill of Govern-Chinese military organisation, ments of far greater experience. there can be little doubt that a On its errors there is no need to. real resistance could have been dilate; at a time of travail errors staged in Jehol. It required the always stand nakedly clear in fervour of national conviction, reproach. They can be used the welding power of a united fruitfully in only one way: to determination, from which all inspire prompt remedial action. personal prejudices, all selfish Tu many' a nation's history it has pecuniary anxieties had been been from disaster that success exorcised, Above all, it demand-has sprung. With that thought ed from the people of Jehol the the Government at Nanking may behind them, Mr. Soong is saying ibe to establish a sounder national apply sanctions it must logical jin far blunter terms what this polity. "The policy of tolerance, be prepared ly to meet all the journal said yesterday in exam. lor in simpler terms, the idea of resultant eventualities Sir John ing the causes of the Jehol encouraging provincial or re-Simon carrottly voiced the views debacle, The frankness which tional autonomy with the Cen-all responsible people when gives him authority thus to tral Government as a general intimated his determination indict his military colleagues mouthpiece for China, is not|to keep Great Britain out of any may perhaps carry him further inconsistent with an immediate military or naval commitment in to critical assessment of the liquidation of the main Sino-this Far Eastern dispute, That extent to which the civil element Japanese problem. It is certain plainly the policy of the in the Government must share that the League of Nations, of United States of America and of the blame. Taking the events of Whose sympathy China has had France, to say nothing of the last year in Shanghai referred to definite proof, is "convinced of|League. It is recognised by by Mr. Soong with pardonable the urgent need for a rapproche-china: it is partly ignored by ride, it may be urged ment between the two countries. Japan because, unhappily, the although the defence of Chapel Outside help can be secured only Japanese Government seems to by the 19th Route Army aroused
deficiencies which Mtr. "Soong fnthusiagm and no little samara the basis of friendliness to-consider its case best served by Wards both parties. It is essen- encouraging supporters—ion, it lamentably ex the that the first step, at any many of whom are more royalist rate, should be direct as between than the king—to spread the rightly blames for the loss of China and Japan, Mr. Soong is notion that there is a conspiracy. Jehol. Without stirring "up. too perspicacious not to reali to attack Japan, Nothing of memories of events best for-that fact. If he carries his|¢ curse is more fatuous, The gotten, it is not unfair to observe Present candour to its logical only basis for propaganda of this that no little of the tribute conclusion he will do more than|kind is to be found in some of accorded to the 19th Route Army realise it. He will give it active|the Jess considered views of was due to perception of its expression by means of advi extremist champions—not of the great inferiority in equipment as. tendered to his colleagues. He League but of the visionary compared with that of the army is perfectly right in maintaining notions which would take the operating eventually against it. the Government has no|League completely out of the There {s no evidence that mea. to despair of the people p! lane of realities, ires were taken to rectify the or even of its own ability. It she ernings thus exposed, has been the victim, as its pr Great Britain, in declaring an National pride is admirable; the revolutionary predecessors were, tions but is taking a step, which embargo, is nol applying sanc-19th Route Army deserved to lof inherently defective receive its glow. Without system. logically should be taken by any national determination, however, In jiesttoying one friendly nation during a state such an emotion is an emotion incubus the revolutionary leaders of war between two countd Tu and nothing more. As an another which is, in some have been forced to give place tothe past there has been far too inspiration it is a disembodied respects, as inert as and, much inconsistency in deploring phantom. The Chinese soldier's others, more sterile than the old. inthe use of the armed argument courage is not impugned. For "Corrupted and paralysed by the but making useful profits out of him commiseration is felt as the taint of archaic and incompetent material supplied to maintain it, im of a vicarious patriotism military professionalism" says Those who recently have b which has been blind to the fact Mr.- Soong of the defeated making so much political capital that to send troops ill-clad, Jarmies. That is the truth but in Geneva and London out of the rrimitively armed and patheticalivil war in Szechuen. must have ly badly equipped against a has shown itself for the whole truth: paralysis been terribly pained to think in the body that the feroci modern army is equivalent to politic which has not been able of the outbreak murder, endure the.tonic of realities was enhanced by bombing aero-'These are all facts requiring but has consistently been planes imported from abroad, no military knowledge to unnourished on the heady draughts The man who tells a small boy leaver. They must have been that smoking is very bad for him lof a spurious self-sufficiency. but at the patent to every member of the Not, otherwise me time presents Government from the Chairman cam be described him—at a price which carries those militant challenges—to downwards. Mr. Soong's state-foreign interests on the insubadditional percentage in recognition of the riskiness of ment could have been made with stantial basis of indefinite for-equal accuracy and greater uselbearance on the part of those of cigarettes, the transaction—with a_ packet fulness a year earlier. Mr. interests. When a Chinese must suffer the Soong no doubt, can show: Minister can, in a tense moment Pangs of a sense of inconsistency even if his bank excellent: reasons why it wa: balance imjof national dismay, so far court, not. It is at least to his credit proves. "The British Government that he has made it now. the risks of unpopularity as tolis endeavouring to protect its speak as frankly as Mr, Soong Moreover his own part in shaking up the administration has done there ig ground for own people from this hardship. Will it be successful? That is satisfaction. He des serves the/the point. with the view of making Great Britain has lear of his countrymen and their had more adapted to cope with experience of the support in acting up to the futility of modern conditions has been de-principles thus plainly prescribe loral gestures in Snitely considerable. The trouble which' she has taken the lead, is that he has not been able to only to find that the performance count on a sufficient volume of is her solo. It is not surprising, therefore, emulation in other departments. to find Sir John Although, for example, good
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.